Baseball GOATLoading rankings
Loading rankings
Ranked by career score. That covers a player’s whole career, not only his time with this team. Players need at least 3 seasons there to make the list.
Gary Sheffield
right field, 1988–2009
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1988–1991, 294 games
Compare with Sutton64.4
No. 61 all-time
Don Sutton
starting pitcher, 1966–1988
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1982–1984, 71 games
Compare with Sheffield57.5
No. 105 all-time
Robin Yount
shortstop, 1974–1993
20 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1974–1993, 2,856 games
Compare with Sheffield55.9
No. 122 all-time
Paul Molitor
designated hitter, 1978–1998
15 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1978–1992, 1,856 games
Compare with Sheffield51.9
No. 165 all-time
Ted Simmons
catcher, 1968–1988
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1981–1985, 665 games
Compare with Sheffield49.1
No. 193 all-time
Sal Bando
third base, 1966–1981
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1977–1981, 551 games
Compare with Sheffield44.4
No. 306 all-time
Ryan Braun
left field, 2007–2020
14 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2007–2020, 1,766 games
Compare with Sheffield44.3
No. 310 all-time
Aramis Ramirez
third base, 1998–2015
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2012–2015, 455 games
Compare with Sheffield41.1
No. 379 all-time
Christian Yelich
left field, 2013–2025
8 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2018–2025, 973 games
Compare with Sheffield38.3
No. 460 all-time
Darrell Porter
catcher, 1971–1987
6 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1971–1976, 537 games
Compare with Sheffield35.6
No. 554 all-time
Prince Fielder
first base, 2005–2016
7 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2005–2011, 998 games
Compare with Sheffield34.7
No. 582 all-time
Cecil Cooper
first base, 1971–1987
11 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1977–1987, 1,490 games
Compare with Sheffield27.3
No. 944 all-time
Kevin Seitzer
third base, 1986–1997
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1992–1996, 539 games
Compare with Sheffield26.3
No. 1,005 all-time
Don Money
third base, 1968–1983
11 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1973–1983, 1,196 games
Compare with Sheffield26.0
No. 1,023 all-time
Rollie Fingers
relief pitcher, 1968–1985
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1981–1985, 177 games
Compare with Sheffield25.8
No. 1,031 all-time
Teddy Higuera
starting pitcher, 1985–1994
9 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1985–1994, 213 games
Compare with Sheffield25.7
No. 1,033 all-time
Larry Hisle
center field, 1968–1982
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1978–1982, 221 games
Compare with Sheffield25.4
No. 1,062 all-time
Gorman Thomas
center field, 1973–1986
11 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1973–1986, 1,103 games
Compare with Sheffield24.9
No. 1,102 all-time
Marquis Grissom
center field, 1989–2005
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1998–2000, 442 games
Compare with Sheffield24.7
No. 1,122 all-time
Willy Adames
shortstop, 2018–2025
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2021–2024, 548 games
Compare with Sheffield24.3
No. 1,154 all-time
Randy Wolf
starting pitcher, 1999–2015
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2010–2012, 95 games
Compare with Sheffield24.3
No. 1,157 all-time
Corbin Burnes
starting pitcher, 2018–2025
6 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2018–2023, 167 games
Compare with Sheffield23.9
No. 1,190 all-time
Jonathan Lucroy
catcher, 2010–2021
7 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2010–2016, 805 games
Compare with Sheffield23.8
No. 1,200 all-time
George Scott
first base, 1966–1979
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1972–1976, 782 games
Compare with Sheffield23.2
No. 1,249 all-time
Jeff Cirillo
third base, 1994–2007
8 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1994–2006, 978 games
Compare with Sheffield23.1
No. 1,260 all-time
Sixto Lezcano
right field, 1974–1985
7 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1974–1980, 785 games
Compare with Sheffield22.8
No. 1,293 all-time
Jean Segura
shortstop, 2012–2023
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2012–2015, 478 games
Compare with Sheffield22.8
No. 1,292 all-time
Yovani Gallardo
starting pitcher, 2007–2018
8 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2007–2014, 220 games
Compare with Sheffield22.6
No. 1,304 all-time
Greg Vaughn
left field, 1989–2003
8 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1989–1996, 903 games
Compare with Sheffield22.3
No. 1,340 all-time
Chris Bosio
starting pitcher, 1986–1996
7 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1986–1992, 212 games
Compare with Sheffield22.1
No. 1,360 all-time
Ben Oglivie
left field, 1971–1986
9 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1978–1986, 1,149 games
Compare with Sheffield22.1
No. 1,354 all-time
Wade Miley
starting pitcher, 2011–2025
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2018–2024, 41 games
Compare with Sheffield21.7
No. 1,397 all-time
Jesse Orosco
relief pitcher, 1979–2003
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1992–1994, 156 games
Compare with Sheffield21.5
No. 1,406 all-time
Richie Sexson
first base, 1997–2008
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2000–2003, 534 games
Compare with Sheffield21.4
No. 1,424 all-time
Rickie Weeks
second base, 2003–2017
11 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2003–2014, 1,142 games
Compare with Sheffield21.4
No. 1,430 all-time
Jeromy Burnitz
right field, 1993–2006
6 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1996–2001, 782 games
Compare with Sheffield21.3
No. 1,433 all-time
Kyle Lohse
starting pitcher, 2001–2016
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2013–2015, 105 games
Compare with Sheffield21.3
No. 1,436 all-time
Francisco Rodriguez
relief pitcher, 2002–2017
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2011–2015, 263 games
Compare with Sheffield21.3
No. 1,443 all-time
John Briggs
left field, 1964–1975
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1971–1975, 584 games
Compare with Sheffield21.2
No. 1,450 all-time
Doug Jones
relief pitcher, 1982–2000
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1982–1998, 149 games
Compare with Sheffield21.1
No. 1,466 all-time
Mark Loretta
second base, 1995–2009
8 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1995–2002, 796 games
Compare with Sheffield21.1
No. 1,459 all-time
Ben Sheets
starting pitcher, 2001–2012
8 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2001–2008, 221 games
Compare with Sheffield21.0
No. 1,477 all-time
Brandon Woodruff
starting pitcher, 2017–2025
8 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2017–2025, 147 games
Compare with Sheffield21.0
No. 1,481 all-time
Jeff Suppan
starting pitcher, 1995–2012
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2007–2010, 113 games
Compare with Sheffield20.6
No. 1,512 all-time
B. J. Surhoff
left field, 1987–2005
9 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1987–1995, 1,102 games
Compare with Sheffield20.1
No. 1,576 all-time
Mike Caldwell
starting pitcher, 1971–1984
8 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1977–1984, 240 games
Compare with Sheffield19.8
No. 1,608 all-time
Jim Slaton
starting pitcher, 1971–1986
12 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1971–1983, 364 games
Compare with Sheffield19.2
No. 1,673 all-time
Jose Valentin
shortstop, 1992–2007
8 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1992–1999, 762 games
Compare with Sheffield19.2
No. 1,678 all-time
Lorenzo Cain
center field, 2010–2022
6 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2010–2022, 458 games
Compare with Sheffield19.0
No. 1,711 all-time
J. J. Hardy
shortstop, 2005–2017
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2005–2009, 571 games
Compare with Sheffield18.8
No. 1,737 all-time
Geoff Jenkins
left field, 1998–2008
10 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1998–2007, 1,234 games
Compare with Sheffield18.8
No. 1,732 all-time
Cal Eldred
starting pitcher, 1991–2005
9 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1991–1999, 178 games
Compare with Sheffield18.0
No. 1,814 all-time
Bob Wickman
relief pitcher, 1992–2007
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1996–2000, 272 games
Compare with Sheffield17.9
No. 1,831 all-time
Pete Vuckovich
starting pitcher, 1975–1986
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1981–1986, 85 games
Compare with Sheffield17.6
No. 1,885 all-time
Carlos Gomez
center field, 2007–2019
6 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2010–2015, 697 games
Compare with Sheffield17.5
No. 1,889 all-time
William Contreras
catcher, 2020–2025
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2023–2025, 446 games
Compare with Sheffield17.4
No. 1,921 all-time
Freddy Peralta
starting pitcher, 2018–2025
8 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2018–2025, 213 games
Compare with Sheffield17.4
No. 1,905 all-time
Ronnie Belliard
second base, 1998–2010
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1998–2002, 489 games
Compare with Sheffield16.7
No. 2,003 all-time
Doug Davis
starting pitcher, 1999–2011
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2003–2010, 119 games
Compare with Sheffield16.5
No. 2,039 all-time
Bill Wegman
starting pitcher, 1985–1995
11 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1985–1995, 266 games
Compare with Sheffield16.2
No. 2,069 all-time
Moose Haas
starting pitcher, 1976–1987
10 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1976–1985, 248 games
Compare with Sheffield16.0
No. 2,100 all-time
Jim Colborn
starting pitcher, 1969–1978
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1972–1976, 183 games
Compare with Sheffield15.8
No. 2,129 all-time
Dan Plesac
relief pitcher, 1986–2003
7 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1986–1992, 365 games
Compare with Sheffield15.6
No. 2,158 all-time
Corey Hart
right field, 2004–2015
9 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2004–2012, 945 games
Compare with Sheffield15.4
No. 2,189 all-time
Jonathan Villar
shortstop, 2013–2022
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2016–2018, 365 games
Compare with Sheffield15.3
No. 2,208 all-time
Reggie Cleveland
starting pitcher, 1969–1981
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1979–1981, 109 games
Compare with Sheffield14.9
No. 2,275 all-time
Lary Sorensen
starting pitcher, 1977–1988
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1977–1980, 129 games
Compare with Sheffield14.9
No. 2,271 all-time
Darryl Hamilton
center field, 1988–2001
7 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1988–1995, 666 games
Compare with Sheffield14.7
No. 2,319 all-time
Khris Davis
left field, 2013–2021
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2013–2015, 321 games
Compare with Sheffield14.6
No. 2,336 all-time
Josh Hader
relief pitcher, 2017–2025
6 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2017–2022, 269 games
Compare with Sheffield14.6
No. 2,338 all-time
Curt Leskanic
relief pitcher, 1993–2004
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2000–2003, 169 games
Compare with Sheffield14.2
No. 2,417 all-time
Jorge De La Rosa
starting pitcher, 2004–2018
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2004–2006, 61 games
Compare with Sheffield14.1
No. 2,445 all-time
Ellie Rodriguez
catcher, 1968–1976
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1971–1973, 325 games
Compare with Sheffield14.0
No. 2,460 all-time
David Weathers
relief pitcher, 1991–2009
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1998–2009, 237 games
Compare with Sheffield14.0
No. 2,453 all-time
Marco Estrada
starting pitcher, 2008–2019
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2010–2014, 139 games
Compare with Sheffield13.9
No. 2,469 all-time
Rob Deer
right field, 1984–1996
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1986–1990, 667 games
Compare with Sheffield13.7
No. 2,505 all-time
Jim Gantner
second base, 1976–1992
17 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1976–1992, 1,801 games
Compare with Sheffield13.0
No. 2,642 all-time
Mike Fiers
starting pitcher, 2011–2021
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2011–2015, 71 games
Compare with Sheffield12.9
No. 2,655 all-time
Matt Garza
starting pitcher, 2006–2017
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2014–2017, 96 games
Compare with Sheffield12.9
No. 2,647 all-time
Charlie Moore
catcher, 1973–1987
14 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1973–1986, 1,283 games
Compare with Sheffield12.7
No. 2,696 all-time
Skip Lockwood
starting pitcher, 1965–1980
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1970–1973, 131 games
Compare with Sheffield12.6
No. 2,700 all-time
Scooter Gennett
second base, 2013–2019
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2013–2016, 456 games
Compare with Sheffield12.5
No. 2,722 all-time
Ken Sanders
relief pitcher, 1964–1976
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1970–1972, 195 games
Compare with Sheffield12.2
No. 2,803 all-time
Jose Hernandez
shortstop, 1991–2006
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2000–2002, 428 games
Compare with Sheffield12.1
No. 2,817 all-time
Jaime Navarro
starting pitcher, 1989–2000
7 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1989–2000, 188 games
Compare with Sheffield12.1
No. 2,824 all-time
John Jaha
first base, 1992–2001
7 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1992–1998, 639 games
Compare with Sheffield11.9
No. 2,866 all-time
Tom Murphy
starting pitcher, 1968–1979
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1974–1976, 138 games
Compare with Sheffield11.9
No. 2,877 all-time
Lyle Overbay
first base, 2001–2014
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2004–2014, 438 games
Compare with Sheffield11.9
No. 2,880 all-time
Damian Miller
catcher, 1997–2007
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2005–2007, 273 games
Compare with Sheffield11.8
No. 2,912 all-time
Dave Nilsson
catcher, 1992–1999
8 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1992–1999, 837 games
Compare with Sheffield11.7
No. 2,917 all-time
Bill Spiers
third base, 1989–2001
6 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1989–1994, 557 games
Compare with Sheffield11.7
No. 2,917 all-time
Fernando Vina
second base, 1993–2004
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1995–1999, 528 games
Compare with Sheffield11.7
No. 2,930 all-time
Mike Adams
relief pitcher, 2004–2014
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2004–2006, 61 games
Compare with Sheffield11.6
No. 2,962 all-time
Zach Davies
starting pitcher, 2015–2023
5 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2015–2019, 115 games
Compare with Sheffield11.6
No. 2,947 all-time
Russell Branyan
third base, 1998–2011
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2004–2008, 186 games
Compare with Sheffield11.5
No. 2,976 all-time
Roy Howell
third base, 1974–1984
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1981–1984, 311 games
Compare with Sheffield11.4
No. 3,009 all-time
Randy Ready
second base, 1983–1995
4 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1983–1986, 120 games
Compare with Sheffield11.3
No. 3,021 all-time
Jamey Wright
starting pitcher, 1996–2014
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2000–2002, 79 games
Compare with Sheffield11.2
No. 3,052 all-time
Omar Narvaez
catcher, 2016–2025
3 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 2020–2022, 247 games
Compare with Sheffield11.0
No. 3,108 all-time
Dave May
center field, 1967–1978
6 seasons on the Milwaukee Brewers, 1970–1978, 717 games
Compare with Sheffield10.9
No. 3,135 all-time