Baseball GOATLoading rankings
Loading rankings
Ranked by career score. That covers a player’s whole career, not only his time with this team. Players need at least 3 seasons there to make the list.
Babe Ruth
right field, 1914–1935
15 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1920–1934, 2,084 games
Compare with Mantle135.5
No. 1 all-time
Mickey Mantle
center field, 1951–1968
18 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1951–1968, 2,401 games
Compare with Ruth93.9
No. 12 all-time
Roger Clemens
starting pitcher, 1984–2007
6 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1999–2007, 175 games
Compare with Ruth93.2
No. 13 all-time
Lou Gehrig
first base, 1923–1939
17 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1923–1939, 2,164 games
Compare with Ruth87.1
No. 17 all-time
Alex Rodriguez
shortstop, 1994–2016
12 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2004–2016, 1,509 games
Compare with Ruth81.9
No. 23 all-time
Rickey Henderson
left field, 1979–2003
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1985–1989, 596 games
Compare with Ruth74.1
No. 36 all-time
Joe DiMaggio
center field, 1936–1951
13 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1936–1951, 1,736 games
Compare with Ruth66.0
No. 55 all-time
Gary Sheffield
right field, 1988–2009
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2004–2006, 347 games
Compare with Ruth64.4
No. 61 all-time
Wade Boggs
third base, 1982–1999
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1993–1997, 602 games
Compare with Ruth63.7
No. 68 all-time
Red Ruffing
starting pitcher, 1924–1947
15 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1930–1946, 631 games
Compare with Ruth63.5
No. 69 all-time
Derek Jeter
shortstop, 1995–2014
20 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1995–2014, 2,747 games
Compare with Ruth63.1
No. 71 all-time
Mike Mussina
starting pitcher, 1991–2008
8 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2001–2008, 249 games
Compare with Ruth58.0
No. 101 all-time
Reggie Jackson
right field, 1967–1987
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1977–1981, 653 games
Compare with Ruth57.9
No. 102 all-time
Whitey Ford
starting pitcher, 1950–1967
16 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1950–1967, 500 games
Compare with Ruth57.3
No. 108 all-time
Carl Mays
starting pitcher, 1915–1929
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1919–1923, 167 games
Compare with Ruth56.3
No. 119 all-time
Johnny Mize
first base, 1936–1953
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1949–1953, 375 games
Compare with Ruth54.7
No. 134 all-time
Urban Shocker
starting pitcher, 1916–1928
6 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1916–1928, 152 games
Compare with Ruth54.5
No. 135 all-time
Aaron Judge
right field, 2016–2025
10 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2016–2025, 1,145 games
Compare with Ruth53.9
No. 141 all-time
Tim Raines
left field, 1979–2002
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1996–1998, 242 games
Compare with Ruth53.6
No. 144 all-time
Dave Winfield
right field, 1973–1995
9 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1981–1990, 1,172 games
Compare with Ruth52.9
No. 150 all-time
Yogi Berra
catcher, 1946–1965
18 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1946–1963, 2,116 games
Compare with Ruth52.2
No. 163 all-time
Jason Giambi
first base, 1995–2014
7 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2002–2008, 897 games
Compare with Ruth49.7
No. 186 all-time
Bobby Abreu
right field, 1996–2014
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2006–2008, 372 games
Compare with Ruth49.5
No. 188 all-time
Robinson Cano
second base, 2005–2022
9 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2005–2013, 1,374 games
Compare with Ruth49.3
No. 189 all-time
CC Sabathia
starting pitcher, 2001–2019
11 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2009–2019, 307 games
Compare with Ruth49.2
No. 191 all-time
Bernie Williams
center field, 1991–2006
16 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1991–2006, 2,076 games
Compare with Ruth49.0
No. 196 all-time
Carlos Beltran
center field, 1998–2017
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2014–2016, 341 games
Compare with Ruth48.9
No. 201 all-time
Tommy John
starting pitcher, 1963–1989
8 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1979–1989, 214 games
Compare with Ruth48.3
No. 211 all-time
Bill Dickey
catcher, 1928–1946
17 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1928–1946, 1,789 games
Compare with Ruth48.1
No. 217 all-time
Waite Hoyt
starting pitcher, 1918–1938
10 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1921–1930, 365 games
Compare with Ruth47.8
No. 224 all-time
David Cone
starting pitcher, 1986–2003
6 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1995–2000, 145 games
Compare with Ruth47.7
No. 230 all-time
Jack Quinn
starting pitcher, 1909–1933
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1919–1921, 112 games
Compare with Ruth47.7
No. 229 all-time
Bob Shawkey
starting pitcher, 1913–1927
13 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1915–1927, 415 games
Compare with Ruth47.6
No. 232 all-time
Home Run Baker
third base, 1908–1922
6 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1916–1922, 676 games
Compare with Ruth46.8
No. 242 all-time
Herb Pennock
starting pitcher, 1912–1934
11 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1923–1933, 346 games
Compare with Ruth45.3
No. 281 all-time
Catfish Hunter
starting pitcher, 1965–1979
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1975–1979, 137 games
Compare with Ruth44.6
No. 297 all-time
Jimmy Key
starting pitcher, 1984–1998
4 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1993–1996, 94 games
Compare with Ruth44.6
No. 299 all-time
Jorge Posada
catcher, 1995–2011
17 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1995–2011, 1,829 games
Compare with Ruth43.8
No. 318 all-time
Lefty Gomez
starting pitcher, 1930–1943
13 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1930–1942, 367 games
Compare with Ruth43.4
No. 329 all-time
Andy Pettitte
starting pitcher, 1995–2013
15 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1995–2013, 447 games
Compare with Ruth42.3
No. 357 all-time
Ron Guidry
starting pitcher, 1975–1988
14 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1975–1988, 380 games
Compare with Ruth41.3
No. 372 all-time
Dwight Gooden
starting pitcher, 1984–2000
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1996–2000, 67 games
Compare with Ruth40.7
No. 386 all-time
Sad Sam Jones
starting pitcher, 1914–1935
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1922–1926, 210 games
Compare with Ruth40.7
No. 385 all-time
Bullet Joe Bush
starting pitcher, 1912–1928
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1922–1924, 138 games
Compare with Ruth40.2
No. 398 all-time
Earle Combs
center field, 1924–1935
12 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1924–1935, 1,456 games
Compare with Ruth40.2
No. 397 all-time
Tony Lazzeri
second base, 1926–1939
12 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1926–1937, 1,659 games
Compare with Ruth39.9
No. 404 all-time
Enos Slaughter
right field, 1938–1959
6 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1954–1959, 350 games
Compare with Ruth39.9
No. 405 all-time
Joe Sewell
shortstop, 1920–1933
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1931–1933, 390 games
Compare with Ruth39.7
No. 410 all-time
Bobby Murcer
center field, 1965–1983
13 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1965–1983, 1,256 games
Compare with Ruth39.6
No. 416 all-time
Charlie Keller
left field, 1939–1952
11 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1939–1952, 1,066 games
Compare with Ruth39.4
No. 422 all-time
Gerrit Cole
starting pitcher, 2013–2024
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2020–2024, 125 games
Compare with Ruth39.3
No. 425 all-time
Wally Schang
catcher, 1913–1931
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1921–1925, 528 games
Compare with Ruth39.2
No. 433 all-time
David Wells
starting pitcher, 1987–2007
4 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1997–2003, 124 games
Compare with Ruth38.6
No. 450 all-time
Graig Nettles
third base, 1967–1988
11 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1973–1983, 1,535 games
Compare with Ruth38.5
No. 452 all-time
Tom Zachary
starting pitcher, 1918–1936
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1928–1930, 36 games
Compare with Ruth38.1
No. 469 all-time
Eddie Lopat
starting pitcher, 1944–1955
8 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1948–1955, 220 games
Compare with Ruth37.8
No. 475 all-time
Willie Randolph
second base, 1975–1992
13 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1976–1988, 1,694 games
Compare with Ruth37.7
No. 480 all-time
Giancarlo Stanton
right field, 2010–2025
8 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2018–2025, 740 games
Compare with Ruth37.2
No. 492 all-time
Mel Stottlemyre
starting pitcher, 1964–1974
11 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1964–1974, 366 games
Compare with Ruth36.9
No. 501 all-time
Darryl Strawberry
right field, 1983–1999
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1995–1999, 231 games
Compare with Ruth36.5
No. 518 all-time
Doyle Alexander
starting pitcher, 1971–1989
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1976–1983, 43 games
Compare with Ruth36.4
No. 519 all-time
Joe Gordon
second base, 1938–1950
7 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1938–1946, 1,000 games
Compare with Ruth36.2
No. 529 all-time
Bump Hadley
starting pitcher, 1926–1941
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1936–1940, 140 games
Compare with Ruth36.2
No. 528 all-time
Brian McCann
catcher, 2005–2019
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2014–2016, 405 games
Compare with Ruth36.2
No. 527 all-time
Chuck Knoblauch
second base, 1991–2002
4 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1998–2001, 539 games
Compare with Ruth35.7
No. 550 all-time
Thurman Munson
catcher, 1969–1979
11 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1969–1979, 1,423 games
Compare with Ruth35.5
No. 559 all-time
Mariano Rivera
relief pitcher, 1995–2013
19 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1995–2013, 1,115 games
Compare with Ruth35.0
No. 571 all-time
Curtis Granderson
center field, 2004–2019
4 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2010–2013, 513 games
Compare with Ruth34.5
No. 586 all-time
Dixie Walker
right field, 1931–1949
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1931–1936, 131 games
Compare with Ruth34.2
No. 597 all-time
Roy White
left field, 1965–1979
15 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1965–1979, 1,881 games
Compare with Ruth34.2
No. 594 all-time
Spud Chandler
starting pitcher, 1937–1947
11 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1937–1947, 211 games
Compare with Ruth33.8
No. 620 all-time
Ray Caldwell
starting pitcher, 1910–1921
6 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1913–1918, 364 games
Compare with Ruth33.3
No. 636 all-time
Johnny Damon
center field, 1995–2012
4 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2006–2009, 576 games
Compare with Ruth33.2
No. 641 all-time
Paul O'Neill
right field, 1985–2001
9 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1993–2001, 1,254 games
Compare with Ruth33.2
No. 646 all-time
Mark Teixeira
first base, 2003–2016
8 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2009–2016, 958 games
Compare with Ruth32.8
No. 654 all-time
Allie Reynolds
starting pitcher, 1942–1954
8 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1947–1954, 314 games
Compare with Ruth32.7
No. 660 all-time
Al Leiter
starting pitcher, 1987–2005
4 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1987–2005, 38 games
Compare with Ruth32.6
No. 665 all-time
Johnny Sain
starting pitcher, 1942–1955
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1951–1955, 143 games
Compare with Ruth32.5
No. 671 all-time
Bobby Shantz
starting pitcher, 1949–1964
4 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1957–1960, 149 games
Compare with Ruth32.2
No. 679 all-time
Don Mattingly
first base, 1982–1995
14 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1982–1995, 1,785 games
Compare with Ruth32.1
No. 684 all-time
Ben Chapman
center field, 1930–1946
7 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1930–1936, 910 games
Compare with Ruth32.0
No. 686 all-time
Ichiro Suzuki
right field, 2001–2019
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2012–2014, 360 games
Compare with Ruth32.0
No. 688 all-time
Ken Griffey
right field, 1973–1991
5 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1982–1986, 551 games
Compare with Ruth31.6
No. 708 all-time
Del Pratt
second base, 1912–1924
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1918–1920, 420 games
Compare with Ruth31.6
No. 710 all-time
Alfonso Soriano
second base, 1999–2014
7 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1999–2014, 626 games
Compare with Ruth31.5
No. 715 all-time
Rich Gossage
relief pitcher, 1972–1994
7 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1978–1989, 319 games
Compare with Ruth31.2
No. 732 all-time
Danny Tartabull
right field, 1984–1997
4 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1992–1995, 424 games
Compare with Ruth31.2
No. 734 all-time
Ken Holtzman
starting pitcher, 1965–1979
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1976–1978, 44 games
Compare with Ruth30.9
No. 742 all-time
Roger Maris
right field, 1957–1968
7 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1960–1966, 850 games
Compare with Ruth30.9
No. 744 all-time
George Mogridge
starting pitcher, 1911–1927
6 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1915–1920, 174 games
Compare with Ruth30.9
No. 748 all-time
Tommy Henrich
right field, 1937–1950
11 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1937–1950, 1,284 games
Compare with Ruth30.5
No. 764 all-time
Bob Watson
first base, 1966–1984
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1980–1982, 196 games
Compare with Ruth30.2
No. 776 all-time
Tiny Bonham
starting pitcher, 1940–1949
7 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1940–1946, 158 games
Compare with Ruth30.0
No. 787 all-time
Anthony Rizzo
first base, 2011–2024
4 seasons on the New York Yankees, 2021–2024, 370 games
Compare with Ruth29.8
No. 794 all-time
Gene Woodling
left field, 1943–1962
6 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1949–1954, 699 games
Compare with Ruth29.8
No. 797 all-time
Jackie Jensen
right field, 1950–1961
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1950–1952, 108 games
Compare with Ruth28.9
No. 849 all-time
Johnny Allen
starting pitcher, 1932–1944
4 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1932–1935, 94 games
Compare with Ruth28.8
No. 857 all-time
Lefty O'Doul
left field, 1919–1934
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1919–1922, 40 games
Compare with Ruth28.6
No. 862 all-time
Don Baylor
designated hitter, 1970–1988
3 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1983–1985, 420 games
Compare with Ruth28.5
No. 872 all-time
Elston Howard
catcher, 1948–1968
13 seasons on the New York Yankees, 1955–1967, 1,492 games
Compare with Ruth28.4
No. 876 all-time