The all-time Pittsburgh Pirates lineup

The best player this franchise has had at each position, 1882–2025, ranked by what he did for the club and not by his whole career. That history includes the Pittsburg Alleghenys (1882–1890).

Full Pittsburgh Pirates rankings

No. 1 at shortstop

Honus Wagner

Pittsburgh Pirates, 1900–1917

Ratings for Honus Wagner
Wins added here	Seasons here	Career score	All-time rank
106.4	18	86.4	18

Ranked by wins added while playing for this franchise, adjusted for era, at the position he played here.

shortstop depth chart

Compare Wagner and Vaughan

Loading lineup

The all-time Pittsburgh Pirates lineup

Honus Wagner

shortstop depth chart

Other teams

The all-time Pittsburgh Pirates lineup

Honus Wagner

shortstop depth chart

Other teams