Baseball GOATLoading rankings
Loading rankings
Ranked by career score. That covers a player’s whole career, not only his time with this team. Players need at least 3 seasons there to make the list.
Barry Bonds
left field, 1986–2007
7 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1986–1992, 1,010 games
Compare with Wagner105.8
No. 5 all-time
Honus Wagner
shortstop, 1897–1917
18 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1900–1917, 2,437 games
Compare with Bonds86.4
No. 18 all-time
Bert Blyleven
starting pitcher, 1970–1992
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1978–1980, 112 games
Compare with Bonds68.4
No. 45 all-time
Vic Willis
starting pitcher, 1898–1910
4 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1906–1909, 160 games
Compare with Bonds64.1
No. 64 all-time
Arky Vaughan
shortstop, 1932–1948
10 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1932–1941, 1,411 games
Compare with Bonds59.5
No. 88 all-time
Paul Waner
right field, 1926–1945
15 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1926–1940, 2,155 games
Compare with Bonds57.4
No. 107 all-time
Wilbur Cooper
starting pitcher, 1912–1926
13 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1912–1924, 473 games
Compare with Bonds56.6
No. 117 all-time
Babe Adams
starting pitcher, 1906–1926
18 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1907–1926, 481 games
Compare with Bonds54.0
No. 140 all-time
Jesse Tannehill
starting pitcher, 1894–1911
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1897–1902, 284 games
Compare with Bonds52.6
No. 154 all-time
Willie Stargell
left field, 1962–1982
21 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1962–1982, 2,360 games
Compare with Bonds51.8
No. 166 all-time
Andrew McCutchen
center field, 2009–2025
12 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 2009–2025, 1,713 games
Compare with Bonds50.9
No. 173 all-time
Burleigh Grimes
starting pitcher, 1916–1934
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1916–1934, 137 games
Compare with Bonds50.5
No. 176 all-time
Pud Galvin
starting pitcher, 1875–1892
7 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1885–1892, 246 games
Compare with Bonds49.9
No. 184 all-time
Ralph Kiner
left field, 1946–1955
8 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1946–1953, 1,095 games
Compare with Bonds49.9
No. 183 all-time
Rick Reuschel
starting pitcher, 1972–1991
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1985–1987, 99 games
Compare with Bonds48.4
No. 207 all-time
Brian Giles
right field, 1995–2009
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1999–2003, 715 games
Compare with Bonds48.3
No. 209 all-time
Sam Leever
starting pitcher, 1898–1910
13 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1898–1910, 389 games
Compare with Bonds48.3
No. 209 all-time
Waite Hoyt
starting pitcher, 1918–1938
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1933–1937, 156 games
Compare with Bonds47.8
No. 224 all-time
Roberto Clemente
right field, 1955–1972
18 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1955–1972, 2,433 games
Compare with Bonds47.7
No. 228 all-time
Elmer Smith
left field, 1886–1901
7 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1892–1901, 766 games
Compare with Bonds47.5
No. 233 all-time
Fred Clarke
left field, 1894–1915
15 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1900–1915, 1,479 games
Compare with Bonds47.4
No. 234 all-time
Deacon Phillippe
starting pitcher, 1899–1911
12 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1900–1911, 334 games
Compare with Bonds45.9
No. 258 all-time
Bob Elliott
third base, 1939–1953
8 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1939–1946, 1,047 games
Compare with Bonds45.1
No. 287 all-time
Adonis Terry
starting pitcher, 1884–1897
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1892–1894, 58 games
Compare with Bonds43.7
No. 321 all-time
Jack Chesbro
starting pitcher, 1899–1909
4 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1899–1902, 122 games
Compare with Bonds43.4
No. 325 all-time
Max Carey
center field, 1910–1929
17 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1910–1926, 2,168 games
Compare with Bonds42.8
No. 341 all-time
Kiki Cuyler
right field, 1921–1938
7 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1921–1927, 525 games
Compare with Bonds42.8
No. 343 all-time
Larry French
starting pitcher, 1929–1942
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1929–1934, 254 games
Compare with Bonds42.5
No. 353 all-time
Aramis Ramirez
third base, 1998–2015
7 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1998–2015, 615 games
Compare with Bonds41.1
No. 379 all-time
Claude Hendrix
starting pitcher, 1911–1920
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1911–1913, 122 games
Compare with Bonds40.4
No. 391 all-time
Bobby Bonilla
third base, 1986–2001
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1986–1991, 843 games
Compare with Bonds39.8
No. 408 all-time
Denny Lyons
third base, 1885–1897
4 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1893–1897, 358 games
Compare with Bonds39.8
No. 406 all-time
Gerrit Cole
starting pitcher, 2013–2024
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 2013–2017, 130 games
Compare with Bonds39.3
No. 425 all-time
Bill Madlock
third base, 1973–1987
7 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1979–1985, 801 games
Compare with Bonds38.7
No. 446 all-time
Murry Dickson
starting pitcher, 1939–1959
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1949–1953, 234 games
Compare with Bonds38.1
No. 467 all-time
Bob Friend
starting pitcher, 1951–1966
15 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1951–1965, 568 games
Compare with Bonds38.0
No. 470 all-time
John Candelaria
starting pitcher, 1975–1993
12 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1975–1993, 348 games
Compare with Bonds37.9
No. 473 all-time
Red Lucas
starting pitcher, 1923–1938
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1934–1938, 276 games
Compare with Bonds37.6
No. 482 all-time
Al Oliver
center field, 1968–1985
10 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1968–1977, 1,302 games
Compare with Bonds37.3
No. 489 all-time
Jason Kendall
catcher, 1996–2010
9 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1996–2004, 1,252 games
Compare with Bonds37.0
No. 497 all-time
Dave Parker
right field, 1973–1991
11 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1973–1983, 1,301 games
Compare with Bonds36.7
No. 507 all-time
Jose Bautista
right field, 2004–2018
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 2004–2008, 400 games
Compare with Bonds36.6
No. 510 all-time
Pink Hawley
starting pitcher, 1892–1901
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1895–1897, 147 games
Compare with Bonds36.5
No. 513 all-time
Ginger Beaumont
center field, 1899–1910
8 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1899–1906, 988 games
Compare with Bonds36.3
No. 524 all-time
Fred Dunlap
second base, 1880–1891
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1888–1890, 220 games
Compare with Bonds35.8
No. 542 all-time
Tommy Leach
third base, 1898–1918
14 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1900–1918, 1,574 games
Compare with Bonds35.8
No. 543 all-time
Jake Beckley
first base, 1888–1907
8 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1888–1896, 930 games
Compare with Bonds35.2
No. 564 all-time
Andy Van Slyke
center field, 1983–1995
8 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1987–1994, 1,057 games
Compare with Bonds35.0
No. 570 all-time
Rick Rhoden
starting pitcher, 1974–1989
8 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1979–1986, 227 games
Compare with Bonds34.9
No. 574 all-time
Preacher Roe
starting pitcher, 1938–1954
4 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1944–1947, 131 games
Compare with Bonds34.1
No. 601 all-time
Frank Killen
starting pitcher, 1891–1900
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1893–1898, 218 games
Compare with Bonds33.8
No. 620 all-time
Jay Bell
shortstop, 1986–2003
8 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1989–1996, 1,106 games
Compare with Bonds33.5
No. 629 all-time
Jerry Reuss
starting pitcher, 1969–1990
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1974–1990, 160 games
Compare with Bonds33.4
No. 632 all-time
Ray Kremer
starting pitcher, 1924–1933
10 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1924–1933, 309 games
Compare with Bonds32.7
No. 661 all-time
Lee Meadows
starting pitcher, 1915–1929
7 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1923–1929, 183 games
Compare with Bonds32.7
No. 661 all-time
Ed Morris
starting pitcher, 1884–1890
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1885–1889, 242 games
Compare with Bonds32.7
No. 658 all-time
Harvey Haddix
starting pitcher, 1952–1965
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1959–1963, 169 games
Compare with Bonds32.0
No. 687 all-time
Doug Drabek
starting pitcher, 1986–1998
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1987–1992, 207 games
Compare with Bonds31.9
No. 692 all-time
Pie Traynor
third base, 1920–1937
17 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1920–1937, 1,941 games
Compare with Bonds31.9
No. 694 all-time
Vern Law
starting pitcher, 1950–1967
16 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1950–1967, 516 games
Compare with Bonds31.8
No. 697 all-time
Howie Pollet
starting pitcher, 1941–1956
4 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1951–1956, 76 games
Compare with Bonds31.5
No. 718 all-time
Richie Hebner
third base, 1968–1985
11 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1968–1983, 1,140 games
Compare with Bonds31.3
No. 730 all-time
Red Ehret
starting pitcher, 1888–1898
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1892–1894, 126 games
Compare with Bonds30.6
No. 762 all-time
George Grantham
second base, 1922–1934
7 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1925–1931, 914 games
Compare with Bonds30.1
No. 784 all-time
Tiny Bonham
starting pitcher, 1940–1949
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1947–1949, 73 games
Compare with Bonds30.0
No. 787 all-time
Lefty Leifield
starting pitcher, 1905–1920
8 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1905–1912, 240 games
Compare with Bonds29.7
No. 803 all-time
Smoky Burgess
catcher, 1949–1967
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1959–1964, 586 games
Compare with Bonds29.6
No. 811 all-time
Fritz Ostermueller
starting pitcher, 1934–1948
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1944–1948, 120 games
Compare with Bonds29.3
No. 826 all-time
Jim Tobin
starting pitcher, 1937–1945
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1937–1939, 120 games
Compare with Bonds29.1
No. 839 all-time
Starling Marte
center field, 2012–2025
8 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 2012–2019, 953 games
Compare with Bonds28.9
No. 847 all-time
Harry Staley
starting pitcher, 1888–1895
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1888–1891, 85 games
Compare with Bonds28.3
No. 887 all-time
Dick Bartell
shortstop, 1927–1946
4 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1927–1930, 345 games
Compare with Bonds28.2
No. 892 all-time
Virgil Davis
catcher, 1928–1945
4 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1940–1945, 233 games
Compare with Bonds27.9
No. 913 all-time
Fred Carroll
catcher, 1884–1891
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1885–1891, 574 games
Compare with Bonds27.7
No. 918 all-time
Bob Bailey
third base, 1962–1978
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1962–1966, 596 games
Compare with Bonds27.4
No. 931 all-time
Ed Swartwood
right field, 1881–1892
4 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1882–1892, 286 games
Compare with Bonds27.4
No. 935 all-time
Jason Schmidt
starting pitcher, 1995–2009
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1996–2001, 129 games
Compare with Bonds27.2
No. 950 all-time
Jake Stenzel
center field, 1890–1899
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1892–1896, 439 games
Compare with Bonds27.2
No. 949 all-time
Howie Camnitz
starting pitcher, 1904–1915
9 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1904–1913, 277 games
Compare with Bonds27.0
No. 960 all-time
Denny Neagle
starting pitcher, 1991–2003
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1992–1996, 192 games
Compare with Bonds27.0
No. 961 all-time
Bob Veale
starting pitcher, 1962–1974
11 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1962–1972, 343 games
Compare with Bonds26.7
No. 982 all-time
Hal Carlson
starting pitcher, 1917–1930
7 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1917–1923, 172 games
Compare with Bonds26.2
No. 1,015 all-time
Rip Sewell
starting pitcher, 1932–1949
12 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1938–1949, 418 games
Compare with Bonds26.2
No. 1,010 all-time
Jason Bay
left field, 2003–2013
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 2003–2008, 719 games
Compare with Bonds25.9
No. 1,029 all-time
Lloyd Waner
center field, 1927–1945
17 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1927–1945, 1,803 games
Compare with Bonds25.7
No. 1,038 all-time
Tom Brown
center field, 1882–1898
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1885–1887, 270 games
Compare with Bonds25.6
No. 1,043 all-time
Mark Baldwin
starting pitcher, 1887–1893
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1891–1893, 110 games
Compare with Bonds25.5
No. 1,055 all-time
Kent Tekulve
relief pitcher, 1974–1989
12 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1974–1985, 722 games
Compare with Bonds25.4
No. 1,063 all-time
Claude Ritchey
second base, 1897–1909
7 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1900–1906, 977 games
Compare with Bonds25.2
No. 1,075 all-time
Richie Zisk
right field, 1971–1983
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1971–1976, 578 games
Compare with Bonds25.2
No. 1,078 all-time
A. J. Burnett
starting pitcher, 1999–2015
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 2012–2015, 87 games
Compare with Bonds24.8
No. 1,111 all-time
Bill Swift
starting pitcher, 1932–1943
8 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1932–1939, 305 games
Compare with Bonds24.6
No. 1,130 all-time
Bob Purkey
starting pitcher, 1954–1966
5 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1954–1966, 111 games
Compare with Bonds24.3
No. 1,152 all-time
Bronson Arroyo
starting pitcher, 2000–2017
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 2000–2002, 54 games
Compare with Bonds24.2
No. 1,164 all-time
Juan Pizarro
starting pitcher, 1957–1974
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1967–1974, 70 games
Compare with Bonds24.0
No. 1,174 all-time
Johnny Morrison
starting pitcher, 1920–1930
8 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1920–1927, 242 games
Compare with Bonds23.9
No. 1,194 all-time
George McQuillan
starting pitcher, 1907–1918
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1913–1915, 100 games
Compare with Bonds23.7
No. 1,204 all-time
Harry Davis
first base, 1895–1917
3 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1896–1898, 213 games
Compare with Bonds23.6
No. 1,213 all-time
John Smiley
starting pitcher, 1986–1997
6 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1986–1991, 196 games
Compare with Bonds23.6
No. 1,210 all-time
Elbie Fletcher
first base, 1934–1949
7 seasons on the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, 1939–1947, 916 games
Compare with Bonds23.4
No. 1,224 all-time