Baseball GOATLoading rankings
Loading rankings
Ranked by career score. That covers a player’s whole career, not only his time with this team. Players need at least 3 seasons there to make the list.
Jose Ramirez
third base, 2013–2025
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2025, 629 games
Compare with Bieber45.1
No. 285 all-time
Shane Bieber
starting pitcher, 2018–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2024, 54 games
Compare with Ramirez23.3
No. 1,239 all-time
Emmanuel Clase
relief pitcher, 2019–2025
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2025, 274 games
Compare with Ramirez10.9
No. 3,147 all-time
Andres Gimenez
second base, 2020–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2024, 451 games
Compare with Ramirez10.6
No. 3,208 all-time
Steven Kwan
left field, 2022–2025
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2025, 583 games
Compare with Ramirez9.6
No. 3,510 all-time
Josh Naylor
first base, 2019–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2024, 395 games
Compare with Ramirez9.1
No. 3,632 all-time
Tanner Bibee
starting pitcher, 2023–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2023–2025, 87 games
Compare with Ramirez8.7
No. 3,784 all-time
Triston McKenzie
starting pitcher, 2020–2025
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2025, 55 games
Compare with Ramirez6.7
No. 4,464 all-time
Gavin Williams
starting pitcher, 2023–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2023–2025, 63 games
Compare with Ramirez6.0
No. 4,790 all-time
Bo Naylor
catcher, 2022–2025
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2025, 318 games
Compare with Ramirez4.0
No. 5,835 all-time
Hunter Gaddis
relief pitcher, 2022–2025
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2025, 164 games
Compare with Ramirez3.8
No. 5,931 all-time
Myles Straw
center field, 2018–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2024, 306 games
Compare with Ramirez3.6
No. 6,041 all-time
Nick Sandlin
relief pitcher, 2021–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2024, 175 games
Compare with Ramirez3.4
No. 6,177 all-time
Logan Allen
starting pitcher, 2023–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2023–2025, 74 games
Compare with Ramirez2.4
No. 6,989 all-time
Tim Herrin
relief pitcher, 2023–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2023–2025, 152 games
Compare with Ramirez2.4
No. 7,036 all-time
Eli Morgan
relief pitcher, 2021–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2024, 143 games
Compare with Ramirez2.2
No. 7,211 all-time
Sam Hentges
relief pitcher, 2021–2024
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2024, 138 games
Compare with Ramirez2.1
No. 7,308 all-time
Tyler Freeman
center field, 2022–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2024, 206 games
Compare with Ramirez1.4
No. 8,087 all-time
Brayan Rocchio
shortstop, 2023–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2023–2025, 281 games
Compare with Ramirez1.3
No. 8,332 all-time
Xzavion Curry
starting pitcher, 2022–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2024, 50 games
Compare with Ramirez0.9
No. 9,152 all-time
Gabriel Arias
shortstop, 2022–2025
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2025, 320 games
Compare with Ramirez0.6
No. 9,944 all-time
Will Brennan
right field, 2022–2025
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2025, 269 games
Compare with Ramirez0.5
No. 10,155 all-time
Austin Hedges
catcher, 2015–2025
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians, 2022–2025, 241 games
Compare with Ramirez0.4
No. 10,605 all-time