Baseball GOATLoading rankings
Loading rankings
Ranked by career score. That covers a player’s whole career, not only his time with this team. Players need at least 3 seasons there to make the list.
Roy Halladay
starting pitcher, 1998–2013
12 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1998–2009, 313 games
Compare with Alomar52.5
No. 155 all-time
Roberto Alomar
second base, 1988–2004
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1991–1995, 703 games
Compare with Halladay52.3
No. 161 all-time
Paul Molitor
designated hitter, 1978–1998
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1993–1995, 405 games
Compare with Halladay51.9
No. 165 all-time
Dave Stieb
starting pitcher, 1979–1998
15 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1979–1998, 450 games
Compare with Halladay51.5
No. 168 all-time
Fred McGriff
first base, 1986–2004
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1986–1990, 578 games
Compare with Halladay45.8
No. 262 all-time
Jimmy Key
starting pitcher, 1984–1998
9 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1984–1992, 318 games
Compare with Halladay44.6
No. 299 all-time
Carlos Delgado
first base, 1993–2009
12 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1993–2004, 1,423 games
Compare with Halladay43.2
No. 334 all-time
Mark Buehrle
starting pitcher, 2000–2015
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2013–2015, 97 games
Compare with Halladay42.6
No. 348 all-time
Josh Donaldson
third base, 2010–2023
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2015–2018, 462 games
Compare with Halladay39.7
No. 414 all-time
John Olerud
first base, 1989–2005
8 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1989–1996, 920 games
Compare with Halladay39.1
No. 434 all-time
David Wells
starting pitcher, 1987–2007
8 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1987–2000, 306 games
Compare with Halladay38.6
No. 450 all-time
Jose Bautista
right field, 2004–2018
10 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2008–2017, 1,235 games
Compare with Halladay36.6
No. 510 all-time
Jose Reyes
shortstop, 2003–2018
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2013–2015, 305 games
Compare with Halladay36.5
No. 516 all-time
Doyle Alexander
starting pitcher, 1971–1989
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1983–1986, 106 games
Compare with Halladay36.4
No. 519 all-time
George Springer
right field, 2014–2025
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2021–2025, 650 games
Compare with Halladay34.8
No. 578 all-time
Chris Carpenter
starting pitcher, 1997–2012
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1997–2002, 152 games
Compare with Halladay33.6
No. 626 all-time
Shawn Green
right field, 1993–2007
7 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1993–1999, 716 games
Compare with Halladay33.5
No. 628 all-time
Troy Tulowitzki
shortstop, 2006–2019
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2015–2017, 238 games
Compare with Halladay33.2
No. 647 all-time
Al Leiter
starting pitcher, 1987–2005
7 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1989–1995, 91 games
Compare with Halladay32.6
No. 665 all-time
Edwin Encarnacion
designated hitter, 2005–2020
8 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2009–2016, 999 games
Compare with Halladay32.2
No. 678 all-time
Tony Fernandez
shortstop, 1983–2001
12 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1983–2001, 1,450 games
Compare with Halladay31.6
No. 712 all-time
Russell Martin
catcher, 2006–2019
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2015–2018, 447 games
Compare with Halladay30.4
No. 768 all-time
Pat Hentgen
starting pitcher, 1991–2004
10 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1991–2004, 270 games
Compare with Halladay29.3
No. 829 all-time
Mike Flanagan
starting pitcher, 1975–1992
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1987–1990, 76 games
Compare with Halladay26.9
No. 971 all-time
Kevin Gausman
starting pitcher, 2013–2025
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2022–2025, 125 games
Compare with Halladay26.8
No. 972 all-time
Vernon Wells
center field, 1999–2013
12 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1999–2010, 1,393 games
Compare with Halladay25.6
No. 1,046 all-time
Woody Williams
starting pitcher, 1993–2007
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1993–1998, 166 games
Compare with Halladay25.6
No. 1,044 all-time
Lloyd Moseby
center field, 1980–1991
10 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1980–1989, 1,392 games
Compare with Halladay25.2
No. 1,073 all-time
Vladimir Guerrero
first base, 2019–2025
7 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2019–2025, 975 games
Compare with Halladay25.1
No. 1,089 all-time
John Mayberry
first base, 1968–1982
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1978–1982, 549 games
Compare with Halladay25.0
No. 1,093 all-time
A. J. Burnett
starting pitcher, 1999–2015
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2006–2008, 81 games
Compare with Halladay24.8
No. 1,111 all-time
Ted Lilly
starting pitcher, 1999–2013
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2004–2006, 89 games
Compare with Halladay24.8
No. 1,112 all-time
Jim Clancy
starting pitcher, 1977–1991
12 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1977–1988, 352 games
Compare with Halladay24.7
No. 1,118 all-time
Devon White
center field, 1985–2001
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1991–1995, 656 games
Compare with Halladay24.7
No. 1,120 all-time
Yunel Escobar
shortstop, 2007–2017
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2010–2012, 338 games
Compare with Halladay23.8
No. 1,196 all-time
Todd Stottlemyre
starting pitcher, 1988–2002
7 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1988–1994, 206 games
Compare with Halladay23.8
No. 1,195 all-time
Raul Mondesi
right field, 1993–2005
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2000–2002, 320 games
Compare with Halladay23.4
No. 1,228 all-time
Bo Bichette
shortstop, 2019–2025
7 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2019–2025, 748 games
Compare with Halladay23.2
No. 1,250 all-time
Juan Samuel
second base, 1983–1998
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1996–1998, 157 games
Compare with Halladay23.2
No. 1,247 all-time
Joe Carter
right field, 1983–1998
7 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1991–1997, 1,039 games
Compare with Halladay22.7
No. 1,295 all-time
R. A. Dickey
starting pitcher, 2001–2017
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2013–2016, 133 games
Compare with Halladay22.7
No. 1,301 all-time
Hyun Jin Ryu
starting pitcher, 2013–2023
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2020–2023, 60 games
Compare with Halladay22.6
No. 1,313 all-time
Juan Guzman
starting pitcher, 1991–2000
8 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1991–1998, 195 games
Compare with Halladay22.4
No. 1,328 all-time
Kelvim Escobar
starting pitcher, 1997–2009
7 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1997–2003, 301 games
Compare with Halladay22.2
No. 1,351 all-time
J. A. Happ
starting pitcher, 2007–2021
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2012–2018, 135 games
Compare with Halladay22.2
No. 1,350 all-time
Mark Eichhorn
relief pitcher, 1982–1996
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1982–1993, 279 games
Compare with Halladay22.0
No. 1,368 all-time
Marcus Stroman
starting pitcher, 2014–2025
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2014–2019, 142 games
Compare with Halladay21.5
No. 1,408 all-time
Jose Berrios
starting pitcher, 2016–2025
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2021–2025, 139 games
Compare with Halladay21.4
No. 1,424 all-time
Chris Bassitt
starting pitcher, 2014–2025
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2023–2025, 96 games
Compare with Halladay21.0
No. 1,480 all-time
George Bell
left field, 1981–1993
9 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1981–1990, 1,181 games
Compare with Halladay21.0
No. 1,474 all-time
Erik Hanson
starting pitcher, 1988–1998
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1996–1998, 49 games
Compare with Halladay20.7
No. 1,498 all-time
Ernie Whitt
catcher, 1976–1991
12 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1977–1989, 1,218 games
Compare with Halladay20.7
No. 1,495 all-time
Jesse Barfield
right field, 1981–1992
9 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1981–1989, 1,032 games
Compare with Halladay20.4
No. 1,537 all-time
Tom Henke
relief pitcher, 1982–1995
8 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1985–1992, 446 games
Compare with Halladay20.4
No. 1,537 all-time
Teoscar Hernandez
right field, 2016–2025
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2017–2022, 609 games
Compare with Halladay19.9
No. 1,595 all-time
Esteban Loaiza
starting pitcher, 1995–2008
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2000–2002, 75 games
Compare with Halladay19.7
No. 1,624 all-time
Dennis Lamp
starting pitcher, 1977–1992
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1984–1986, 149 games
Compare with Halladay19.6
No. 1,634 all-time
Mike Timlin
relief pitcher, 1991–2008
7 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1991–1997, 305 games
Compare with Halladay19.6
No. 1,636 all-time
Shannon Stewart
left field, 1995–2008
10 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1995–2008, 907 games
Compare with Halladay19.5
No. 1,648 all-time
Cecil Fielder
first base, 1985–1998
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1985–1988, 220 games
Compare with Halladay19.3
No. 1,665 all-time
Cliff Johnson
designated hitter, 1972–1986
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1983–1986, 400 games
Compare with Halladay19.2
No. 1,688 all-time
Aaron Hill
second base, 2005–2017
7 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2005–2011, 875 games
Compare with Halladay18.7
No. 1,748 all-time
Paul Quantrill
relief pitcher, 1992–2005
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1996–2001, 386 games
Compare with Halladay18.2
No. 1,795 all-time
Alex Rios
right field, 2004–2015
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2004–2009, 809 games
Compare with Halladay18.0
No. 1,818 all-time
Mookie Wilson
center field, 1980–1991
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1989–1991, 287 games
Compare with Halladay17.3
No. 1,931 all-time
Orlando Hudson
second base, 2002–2012
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2002–2005, 462 games
Compare with Halladay17.0
No. 1,960 all-time
Darrin Fletcher
catcher, 1989–2002
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1998–2002, 540 games
Compare with Halladay16.4
No. 2,054 all-time
Rance Mulliniks
third base, 1977–1992
11 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1982–1992, 1,115 games
Compare with Halladay16.0
No. 2,092 all-time
Jose Cruz
center field, 1997–2008
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1997–2002, 698 games
Compare with Halladay15.7
No. 2,150 all-time
Dan Plesac
relief pitcher, 1986–2003
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1997–2002, 262 games
Compare with Halladay15.6
No. 2,158 all-time
Shaun Marcum
starting pitcher, 2005–2015
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2005–2010, 120 games
Compare with Halladay14.9
No. 2,271 all-time
Gregg Zaun
catcher, 1995–2010
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2004–2008, 535 games
Compare with Halladay14.8
No. 2,294 all-time
Colby Rasmus
center field, 2009–2018
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2011–2014, 408 games
Compare with Halladay14.3
No. 2,384 all-time
Marco Estrada
starting pitcher, 2008–2019
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2015–2018, 124 games
Compare with Halladay13.9
No. 2,469 all-time
Glenallen Hill
right field, 1989–2001
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1989–1991, 138 games
Compare with Halladay13.9
No. 2,483 all-time
Duane Ward
relief pitcher, 1986–1995
9 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1986–1995, 452 games
Compare with Halladay13.9
No. 2,465 all-time
Kelly Gruber
third base, 1984–1993
9 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1984–1992, 921 games
Compare with Halladay13.6
No. 2,530 all-time
Danny Cox
starting pitcher, 1983–1995
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1993–1995, 78 games
Compare with Halladay13.5
No. 2,535 all-time
Adam Lind
first base, 2006–2017
9 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2006–2014, 953 games
Compare with Halladay12.5
No. 2,719 all-time
Lourdes Gurriel
left field, 2018–2025
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2018–2022, 468 games
Compare with Halladay12.4
No. 2,759 all-time
B. J. Ryan
relief pitcher, 1999–2009
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2006–2009, 155 games
Compare with Halladay12.4
No. 2,752 all-time
Frank Catalanotto
left field, 1997–2010
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2003–2006, 466 games
Compare with Halladay12.3
No. 2,767 all-time
Scott Downs
relief pitcher, 2000–2014
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2005–2010, 347 games
Compare with Halladay12.3
No. 2,770 all-time
Randal Grichuk
center field, 2014–2025
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2018–2021, 479 games
Compare with Halladay12.3
No. 2,774 all-time
Candy Maldonado
right field, 1981–1995
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1991–1995, 250 games
Compare with Halladay12.1
No. 2,817 all-time
Luis Leal
starting pitcher, 1980–1985
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1980–1985, 165 games
Compare with Halladay11.9
No. 2,861 all-time
Tom Murphy
starting pitcher, 1968–1979
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1977–1979, 79 games
Compare with Halladay11.9
No. 2,877 all-time
Lyle Overbay
first base, 2001–2014
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2006–2010, 723 games
Compare with Halladay11.9
No. 2,880 all-time
Justin Speier
relief pitcher, 1998–2009
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2004–2006, 185 games
Compare with Halladay11.8
No. 2,903 all-time
Rick Cerone
catcher, 1975–1992
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1977–1979, 255 games
Compare with Halladay11.7
No. 2,934 all-time
Jason Frasor
relief pitcher, 2004–2015
9 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2004–2012, 505 games
Compare with Halladay11.7
No. 2,941 all-time
Tony Batista
third base, 1996–2007
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1999–2001, 324 games
Compare with Halladay11.5
No. 2,968 all-time
Alejandro Kirk
catcher, 2020–2025
6 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2020–2025, 564 games
Compare with Halladay11.5
No. 2,987 all-time
Roy Howell
third base, 1974–1984
4 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1977–1980, 516 games
Compare with Halladay11.4
No. 3,009 all-time
Mitch Webster
center field, 1983–1995
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1983–1985, 41 games
Compare with Halladay11.4
No. 3,000 all-time
Joey Hamilton
starting pitcher, 1994–2003
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1999–2001, 50 games
Compare with Halladay11.0
No. 3,101 all-time
Danny Jansen
catcher, 2018–2025
7 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2018–2024, 471 games
Compare with Halladay11.0
No. 3,121 all-time
Jim Gott
relief pitcher, 1982–1995
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 1982–1984, 99 games
Compare with Halladay10.8
No. 3,173 all-time
Brandon Morrow
starting pitcher, 2007–2018
5 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2010–2014, 100 games
Compare with Halladay10.7
No. 3,187 all-time
Brandon Lyon
relief pitcher, 2001–2013
3 seasons on the Toronto Blue Jays, 2001–2012, 56 games
Compare with Halladay10.4
No. 3,287 all-time