Baseball GOATLoading rankings
Loading rankings
Ranked by career score. That covers a player’s whole career, not only his time with this team. Players need at least 3 seasons there to make the list.
Pete Alexander
starting pitcher, 1911–1930
8 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1911–1930, 345 games
Compare with Keefe96.1
No. 9 all-time
Tim Keefe
starting pitcher, 1880–1893
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1891–1893, 72 games
Compare with Alexander74.8
No. 32 all-time
Nap Lajoie
second base, 1896–1916
5 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1896–1900, 492 games
Compare with Alexander74.3
No. 35 all-time
Steve Carlton
starting pitcher, 1965–1988
15 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1972–1986, 501 games
Compare with Alexander72.6
No. 38 all-time
Mike Schmidt
third base, 1972–1989
18 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1972–1989, 2,404 games
Compare with Alexander71.8
No. 40 all-time
Robin Roberts
starting pitcher, 1948–1966
14 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1948–1961, 541 games
Compare with Alexander68.9
No. 44 all-time
Ed Delahanty
left field, 1888–1903
13 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1888–1901, 1,557 games
Compare with Alexander62.7
No. 74 all-time
Curt Schilling
starting pitcher, 1988–2007
9 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1992–2000, 244 games
Compare with Alexander60.7
No. 78 all-time
Pete Rose
third base, 1963–1986
5 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1979–1983, 745 games
Compare with Alexander59.6
No. 87 all-time
Jim Thome
first base, 1991–2012
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2003–2012, 391 games
Compare with Alexander58.4
No. 98 all-time
Dick Allen
third base, 1963–1977
9 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1963–1976, 1,070 games
Compare with Alexander57.6
No. 104 all-time
Billy Hamilton
center field, 1888–1901
6 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1890–1895, 732 games
Compare with Alexander57.2
No. 112 all-time
Charlie Buffinton
starting pitcher, 1882–1892
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1887–1889, 159 games
Compare with Alexander57.0
No. 114 all-time
Jim Bunning
starting pitcher, 1955–1971
6 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1964–1971, 229 games
Compare with Alexander54.8
No. 132 all-time
Eppa Rixey
starting pitcher, 1912–1933
8 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1912–1920, 254 games
Compare with Alexander54.0
No. 137 all-time
Bucky Walters
starting pitcher, 1931–1950
5 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1934–1938, 268 games
Compare with Alexander53.6
No. 145 all-time
Roy Halladay
starting pitcher, 1998–2013
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2010–2013, 103 games
Compare with Alexander52.5
No. 155 all-time
Andrew McCutchen
center field, 2009–2025
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2019–2021, 260 games
Compare with Alexander50.9
No. 173 all-time
Bobby Abreu
right field, 1996–2014
9 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1998–2006, 1,353 games
Compare with Alexander49.5
No. 188 all-time
Jim Kaat
starting pitcher, 1959–1983
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1976–1979, 107 games
Compare with Alexander46.5
No. 246 all-time
Elmer Flick
right field, 1898–1910
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1898–1901, 537 games
Compare with Alexander46.4
No. 247 all-time
Bryce Harper
right field, 2012–2025
7 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2019–2025, 858 games
Compare with Alexander46.2
No. 251 all-time
Cole Hamels
starting pitcher, 2006–2020
10 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2006–2015, 302 games
Compare with Alexander46.1
No. 255 all-time
Chuck Klein
right field, 1928–1944
15 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1928–1944, 1,405 games
Compare with Alexander45.6
No. 268 all-time
Al Orth
starting pitcher, 1895–1909
7 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1895–1901, 230 games
Compare with Alexander45.6
No. 269 all-time
Scott Rolen
third base, 1996–2012
7 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1996–2002, 844 games
Compare with Alexander45.5
No. 274 all-time
Richie Ashburn
center field, 1948–1962
12 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1948–1959, 1,794 games
Compare with Alexander45.4
No. 276 all-time
Dale Murphy
center field, 1976–1993
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1990–1992, 228 games
Compare with Alexander45.4
No. 279 all-time
Sherry Magee
left field, 1904–1919
11 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1904–1914, 1,521 games
Compare with Alexander44.7
No. 295 all-time
Roy Thomas
center field, 1899–1911
12 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1899–1911, 1,287 games
Compare with Alexander43.9
No. 317 all-time
Larry Jackson
starting pitcher, 1955–1968
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1966–1968, 115 games
Compare with Alexander43.4
No. 326 all-time
Sam Thompson
right field, 1885–1906
10 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1889–1898, 1,034 games
Compare with Alexander43.2
No. 332 all-time
Chase Utley
second base, 2003–2018
13 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2003–2015, 1,551 games
Compare with Alexander41.6
No. 367 all-time
Jamie Moyer
starting pitcher, 1986–2012
5 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2006–2010, 124 games
Compare with Alexander41.5
No. 368 all-time
Cy Williams
center field, 1912–1930
13 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1918–1930, 1,463 games
Compare with Alexander41.1
No. 380 all-time
Schoolboy Rowe
starting pitcher, 1933–1949
5 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1943–1949, 210 games
Compare with Alexander40.4
No. 391 all-time
Trea Turner
shortstop, 2015–2025
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2023–2025, 417 games
Compare with Alexander39.3
No. 428 all-time
Gus Weyhing
starting pitcher, 1887–1901
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1892–1895, 151 games
Compare with Alexander39.3
No. 425 all-time
Claude Passeau
starting pitcher, 1935–1947
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1936–1939, 153 games
Compare with Alexander39.0
No. 438 all-time
Curt Simmons
starting pitcher, 1947–1967
13 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1947–1960, 357 games
Compare with Alexander38.6
No. 449 all-time
Curt Davis
starting pitcher, 1934–1946
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1934–1936, 108 games
Compare with Alexander38.4
No. 457 all-time
Murry Dickson
starting pitcher, 1939–1959
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1954–1956, 79 games
Compare with Alexander38.1
No. 467 all-time
Hugh Duffy
center field, 1888–1906
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1904–1906, 34 games
Compare with Alexander37.5
No. 483 all-time
Cliff Lee
starting pitcher, 2002–2014
5 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2009–2014, 127 games
Compare with Alexander37.5
No. 485 all-time
Bill Nicholson
right field, 1936–1953
5 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1949–1953, 318 games
Compare with Alexander37.3
No. 490 all-time
Kid Gleason
starting pitcher, 1888–1912
10 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1888–1908, 767 games
Compare with Alexander36.8
No. 504 all-time
Dolph Camilli
first base, 1933–1945
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1934–1937, 539 games
Compare with Alexander36.6
No. 512 all-time
Gavvy Cravath
right field, 1908–1920
9 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1912–1920, 1,104 games
Compare with Alexander36.3
No. 526 all-time
Bill Lee
starting pitcher, 1934–1947
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1943–1945, 57 games
Compare with Alexander35.7
No. 549 all-time
Greg Luzinski
left field, 1970–1984
11 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1970–1980, 1,289 games
Compare with Alexander35.6
No. 555 all-time
Charlie Ferguson
starting pitcher, 1884–1887
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1884–1887, 257 games
Compare with Alexander35.0
No. 572 all-time
Jimmy Rollins
shortstop, 2000–2016
15 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2000–2014, 2,090 games
Compare with Alexander34.2
No. 595 all-time
Earl Moore
starting pitcher, 1901–1914
6 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1908–1913, 172 games
Compare with Alexander33.5
No. 630 all-time
Zack Wheeler
starting pitcher, 2013–2025
6 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2020–2025, 158 games
Compare with Alexander33.4
No. 634 all-time
Lenny Dykstra
center field, 1985–1996
8 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1989–1996, 734 games
Compare with Alexander33.3
No. 638 all-time
Dave Bancroft
shortstop, 1915–1930
6 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1915–1920, 681 games
Compare with Alexander33.2
No. 641 all-time
Lee Meadows
starting pitcher, 1915–1929
5 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1919–1923, 129 games
Compare with Alexander32.7
No. 661 all-time
Roy Sievers
left field, 1949–1965
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1962–1964, 331 games
Compare with Alexander32.7
No. 663 all-time
Gary Matthews
left field, 1972–1987
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1981–1983, 395 games
Compare with Alexander31.8
No. 696 all-time
J. T. Realmuto
catcher, 2014–2025
7 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2019–2025, 833 games
Compare with Alexander31.4
No. 721 all-time
Rick Wise
starting pitcher, 1964–1982
7 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1964–1971, 223 games
Compare with Alexander31.4
No. 720 all-time
Del Ennis
left field, 1946–1959
11 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1946–1956, 1,630 games
Compare with Alexander30.5
No. 765 all-time
Dode Paskert
center field, 1907–1921
7 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1911–1917, 953 games
Compare with Alexander29.9
No. 791 all-time
Smoky Burgess
catcher, 1949–1967
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1952–1955, 327 games
Compare with Alexander29.6
No. 811 all-time
Lave Cross
third base, 1887–1907
6 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1892–1897, 677 games
Compare with Alexander29.3
No. 827 all-time
John Titus
right field, 1903–1913
10 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1903–1912, 1,219 games
Compare with Alexander29.0
No. 841 all-time
Darren Daulton
catcher, 1983–1997
14 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1983–1997, 1,109 games
Compare with Alexander28.9
No. 850 all-time
Deacon McGuire
catcher, 1884–1912
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1886–1888, 103 games
Compare with Alexander28.7
No. 859 all-time
Dick Bartell
shortstop, 1927–1946
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1931–1934, 587 games
Compare with Alexander28.2
No. 892 all-time
Jack Clements
catcher, 1884–1900
14 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1884–1897, 1,000 games
Compare with Alexander28.2
No. 895 all-time
Jayson Werth
right field, 2002–2017
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2007–2010, 543 games
Compare with Alexander28.2
No. 894 all-time
Tom Gordon
starting pitcher, 1988–2009
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2006–2008, 137 games
Compare with Alexander28.1
No. 899 all-time
Syl Johnson
starting pitcher, 1922–1940
7 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1934–1940, 211 games
Compare with Alexander28.0
No. 905 all-time
Virgil Davis
catcher, 1928–1945
8 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1928–1939, 814 games
Compare with Alexander27.9
No. 913 all-time
Aaron Nola
starting pitcher, 2015–2025
11 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2015–2025, 286 games
Compare with Alexander27.8
No. 915 all-time
Ken Raffensberger
starting pitcher, 1939–1954
5 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1943–1947, 93 games
Compare with Alexander27.5
No. 929 all-time
Chris Short
starting pitcher, 1959–1973
14 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1959–1972, 464 games
Compare with Alexander27.3
No. 941 all-time
Lonnie Smith
left field, 1978–1994
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1978–1981, 196 games
Compare with Alexander27.3
No. 944 all-time
Billy Nash
third base, 1884–1898
3 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1896–1898, 189 games
Compare with Alexander27.1
No. 955 all-time
Ron Reed
starting pitcher, 1966–1984
8 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1976–1983, 458 games
Compare with Alexander26.7
No. 977 all-time
Red Donahue
starting pitcher, 1893–1906
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1898–1901, 136 games
Compare with Alexander26.5
No. 987 all-time
Johnny Callison
right field, 1958–1973
10 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1960–1969, 1,432 games
Compare with Alexander26.4
No. 999 all-time
Hal Carlson
starting pitcher, 1917–1930
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1924–1927, 127 games
Compare with Alexander26.2
No. 1,015 all-time
Andy Seminick
catcher, 1943–1957
12 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1943–1957, 985 games
Compare with Alexander26.2
No. 1,011 all-time
Don Money
third base, 1968–1983
5 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1968–1972, 524 games
Compare with Alexander26.0
No. 1,023 all-time
John Denny
starting pitcher, 1974–1986
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1982–1985, 95 games
Compare with Alexander25.8
No. 1,032 all-time
Tim McCarver
catcher, 1959–1980
9 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1970–1980, 628 games
Compare with Alexander25.7
No. 1,042 all-time
Larry Hisle
center field, 1968–1982
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1968–1971, 314 games
Compare with Alexander25.4
No. 1,062 all-time
Kent Tekulve
relief pitcher, 1974–1989
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1985–1988, 291 games
Compare with Alexander25.4
No. 1,063 all-time
Pat Burrell
left field, 2000–2011
9 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2000–2008, 1,306 games
Compare with Alexander25.1
No. 1,086 all-time
Ryan Howard
first base, 2004–2016
13 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2004–2016, 1,572 games
Compare with Alexander24.8
No. 1,106 all-time
Tully Sparks
starting pitcher, 1897–1910
9 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1897–1910, 224 games
Compare with Alexander24.8
No. 1,115 all-time
John Kruk
first base, 1986–1995
6 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1989–1994, 744 games
Compare with Alexander24.7
No. 1,123 all-time
Tony Gonzalez
center field, 1960–1971
9 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1960–1968, 1,118 games
Compare with Alexander24.6
No. 1,132 all-time
Kyle Schwarber
left field, 2015–2025
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 2022–2025, 627 games
Compare with Alexander24.5
No. 1,136 all-time
Randy Wolf
starting pitcher, 1999–2015
8 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1999–2006, 200 games
Compare with Alexander24.3
No. 1,157 all-time
George Wood
left field, 1880–1892
4 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1886–1889, 422 games
Compare with Alexander24.3
No. 1,157 all-time
Willie Jones
third base, 1947–1961
13 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1947–1959, 1,520 games
Compare with Alexander24.2
No. 1,160 all-time
Von Hayes
first base, 1981–1992
9 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1983–1991, 1,208 games
Compare with Alexander24.1
No. 1,169 all-time
Jack Taylor
starting pitcher, 1891–1899
6 seasons on the Philadelphia Phillies franchise, 1892–1897, 208 games
Compare with Alexander23.9
No. 1,184 all-time