Baseball GOATLoading rankings
Loading rankings
Ranked by career score. That covers a player’s whole career, not only his time with this team. Players need at least 3 seasons there to make the list.
Tom Seaver
starting pitcher, 1967–1986
12 seasons on the New York Mets, 1967–1983, 420 games
Compare with Martinez83.0
No. 21 all-time
Pedro Martinez
starting pitcher, 1992–2009
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 2005–2008, 79 games
Compare with Seaver66.1
No. 54 all-time
Tom Glavine
starting pitcher, 1987–2008
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 2003–2007, 168 games
Compare with Seaver65.2
No. 59 all-time
Mike Piazza
catcher, 1992–2007
8 seasons on the New York Mets, 1998–2005, 972 games
Compare with Seaver62.9
No. 72 all-time
Nolan Ryan
starting pitcher, 1966–1993
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1966–1971, 105 games
Compare with Seaver57.2
No. 113 all-time
51.3
No. 169 all-time
Gary Carter
catcher, 1974–1992
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1985–1989, 600 games
Compare with Seaver50.3
No. 178 all-time
Robinson Cano
second base, 2005–2022
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 2019–2022, 168 games
Compare with Seaver49.3
No. 189 all-time
Carlos Beltran
center field, 1998–2017
7 seasons on the New York Mets, 2005–2011, 839 games
Compare with Seaver48.9
No. 201 all-time
Jeff Kent
second base, 1992–2008
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1992–1996, 498 games
Compare with Seaver48.9
No. 200 all-time
David Cone
starting pitcher, 1986–2003
7 seasons on the New York Mets, 1987–2003, 188 games
Compare with Seaver47.7
No. 230 all-time
David Wright
third base, 2004–2018
14 seasons on the New York Mets, 2004–2018, 1,585 games
Compare with Seaver47.6
No. 231 all-time
Bret Saberhagen
starting pitcher, 1984–2001
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 1992–1995, 76 games
Compare with Seaver47.2
No. 236 all-time
Johan Santana
starting pitcher, 2000–2012
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 2008–2012, 109 games
Compare with Seaver46.1
No. 253 all-time
Jerry Koosman
starting pitcher, 1967–1985
12 seasons on the New York Mets, 1967–1978, 376 games
Compare with Seaver45.4
No. 277 all-time
Carlos Delgado
first base, 1993–2009
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 2006–2009, 468 games
Compare with Seaver43.2
No. 334 all-time
Francisco Lindor
shortstop, 2015–2025
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 2021–2025, 758 games
Compare with Seaver42.8
No. 339 all-time
Rusty Staub
right field, 1963–1985
9 seasons on the New York Mets, 1972–1985, 942 games
Compare with Seaver42.3
No. 355 all-time
Frank Viola
starting pitcher, 1982–1996
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1989–1991, 82 games
Compare with Seaver42.1
No. 362 all-time
Dwight Gooden
starting pitcher, 1984–2000
11 seasons on the New York Mets, 1984–1994, 309 games
Compare with Seaver40.7
No. 386 all-time
Bobby Bonilla
third base, 1986–2001
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1992–1999, 515 games
Compare with Seaver39.8
No. 408 all-time
Jacob deGrom
starting pitcher, 2014–2025
9 seasons on the New York Mets, 2014–2022, 221 games
Compare with Seaver39.7
No. 412 all-time
John Olerud
first base, 1989–2005
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1997–1999, 476 games
Compare with Seaver39.1
No. 434 all-time
George Foster
left field, 1969–1986
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1982–1986, 655 games
Compare with Seaver38.8
No. 444 all-time
Bartolo Colon
starting pitcher, 1997–2018
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 2014–2016, 98 games
Compare with Seaver37.8
No. 476 all-time
Jose Reyes
shortstop, 2003–2018
12 seasons on the New York Mets, 2003–2018, 1,365 games
Compare with Seaver36.5
No. 516 all-time
Darryl Strawberry
right field, 1983–1999
8 seasons on the New York Mets, 1983–1990, 1,109 games
Compare with Seaver36.5
No. 518 all-time
Keith Hernandez
first base, 1974–1990
7 seasons on the New York Mets, 1983–1989, 880 games
Compare with Seaver35.7
No. 547 all-time
Robin Ventura
third base, 1989–2004
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1999–2001, 444 games
Compare with Seaver35.7
No. 546 all-time
Curtis Granderson
center field, 2004–2019
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 2014–2017, 573 games
Compare with Seaver34.5
No. 586 all-time
Justin Turner
third base, 2009–2025
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 2010–2013, 301 games
Compare with Seaver34.4
No. 590 all-time
Jon Matlack
starting pitcher, 1971–1983
7 seasons on the New York Mets, 1971–1977, 204 games
Compare with Seaver33.7
No. 625 all-time
Zack Wheeler
starting pitcher, 2013–2025
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 2013–2019, 130 games
Compare with Seaver33.4
No. 634 all-time
Lenny Dykstra
center field, 1985–1996
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1985–1989, 544 games
Compare with Seaver33.3
No. 638 all-time
Al Leiter
starting pitcher, 1987–2005
7 seasons on the New York Mets, 1998–2004, 213 games
Compare with Seaver32.6
No. 665 all-time
Howard Johnson
third base, 1982–1995
9 seasons on the New York Mets, 1985–1993, 1,154 games
Compare with Seaver31.4
No. 721 all-time
Asdrubal Cabrera
shortstop, 2007–2021
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 2016–2018, 374 games
Compare with Seaver29.1
No. 835 all-time
Sid Fernandez
starting pitcher, 1983–1997
10 seasons on the New York Mets, 1984–1993, 256 games
Compare with Seaver29.0
No. 842 all-time
Starling Marte
center field, 2012–2025
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 2022–2025, 396 games
Compare with Seaver28.9
No. 847 all-time
Brandon Nimmo
center field, 2016–2025
10 seasons on the New York Mets, 2016–2025, 1,066 games
Compare with Seaver27.5
No. 928 all-time
Todd Zeile
third base, 1989–2004
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 2000–2004, 441 games
Compare with Seaver27.5
No. 930 all-time
Edgardo Alfonzo
third base, 1995–2006
8 seasons on the New York Mets, 1995–2002, 1,086 games
Compare with Seaver27.0
No. 963 all-time
Ron Hunt
second base, 1963–1974
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 1963–1966, 459 games
Compare with Seaver26.1
No. 1,018 all-time
Jason Bay
left field, 2003–2013
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 2010–2012, 288 games
Compare with Seaver25.9
No. 1,029 all-time
Cliff Floyd
left field, 1993–2009
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 2003–2006, 468 games
Compare with Seaver24.9
No. 1,098 all-time
Daniel Murphy
second base, 2008–2020
7 seasons on the New York Mets, 2008–2015, 903 games
Compare with Seaver24.9
No. 1,103 all-time
Billy Wagner
relief pitcher, 1995–2010
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 2006–2009, 183 games
Compare with Seaver24.8
No. 1,109 all-time
Kevin McReynolds
left field, 1983–1994
6 seasons on the New York Mets, 1987–1994, 787 games
Compare with Seaver24.6
No. 1,131 all-time
Pete Alonso
first base, 2019–2025
7 seasons on the New York Mets, 2019–2025, 1,007 games
Compare with Seaver24.3
No. 1,148 all-time
Steve Trachsel
starting pitcher, 1993–2008
6 seasons on the New York Mets, 2001–2006, 166 games
Compare with Seaver24.1
No. 1,173 all-time
Tug McGraw
relief pitcher, 1965–1984
9 seasons on the New York Mets, 1965–1974, 363 games
Compare with Seaver23.7
No. 1,202 all-time
Carlos Carrasco
starting pitcher, 2009–2025
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 2021–2023, 61 games
Compare with Seaver23.4
No. 1,234 all-time
Luis Castillo
second base, 1996–2010
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 2007–2010, 365 games
Compare with Seaver23.2
No. 1,257 all-time
R. A. Dickey
starting pitcher, 2001–2017
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 2010–2012, 94 games
Compare with Seaver22.7
No. 1,301 all-time
Mike Scott
starting pitcher, 1979–1991
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 1979–1982, 84 games
Compare with Seaver22.7
No. 1,302 all-time
Ray Sadecki
starting pitcher, 1960–1977
6 seasons on the New York Mets, 1970–1977, 165 games
Compare with Seaver22.6
No. 1,308 all-time
Frank Thomas
left field, 1951–1966
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1962–1964, 342 games
Compare with Seaver22.5
No. 1,320 all-time
Pete Harnisch
starting pitcher, 1988–2001
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1995–1997, 56 games
Compare with Seaver22.1
No. 1,357 all-time
Todd Hundley
catcher, 1990–2003
9 seasons on the New York Mets, 1990–1998, 829 games
Compare with Seaver22.1
No. 1,360 all-time
John Franco
relief pitcher, 1984–2005
14 seasons on the New York Mets, 1990–2004, 695 games
Compare with Seaver21.8
No. 1,390 all-time
Gregg Jefferies
first base, 1987–2000
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1987–1991, 465 games
Compare with Seaver21.6
No. 1,402 all-time
Rick Reed
starting pitcher, 1988–2003
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1997–2001, 141 games
Compare with Seaver21.6
No. 1,403 all-time
Dave Kingman
left field, 1971–1986
6 seasons on the New York Mets, 1975–1983, 664 games
Compare with Seaver21.5
No. 1,410 all-time
Jesse Orosco
relief pitcher, 1979–2003
8 seasons on the New York Mets, 1979–1987, 372 games
Compare with Seaver21.5
No. 1,406 all-time
Jeromy Burnitz
right field, 1993–2006
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 1993–2003, 350 games
Compare with Seaver21.3
No. 1,433 all-time
Francisco Rodriguez
relief pitcher, 2002–2017
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 2009–2011, 165 games
Compare with Seaver21.3
No. 1,443 all-time
Tommie Agee
center field, 1962–1973
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1968–1972, 661 games
Compare with Seaver21.1
No. 1,467 all-time
Carlos Baerga
second base, 1990–2005
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1996–1998, 306 games
Compare with Seaver20.6
No. 1,506 all-time
Todd Frazier
third base, 2011–2021
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 2018–2020, 262 games
Compare with Seaver20.6
No. 1,507 all-time
Bob Ojeda
starting pitcher, 1980–1994
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1986–1990, 142 games
Compare with Seaver20.4
No. 1,540 all-time
Lee Mazzilli
center field, 1976–1989
10 seasons on the New York Mets, 1976–1989, 979 games
Compare with Seaver20.3
No. 1,551 all-time
Jeff McNeil
second base, 2018–2025
8 seasons on the New York Mets, 2018–2025, 923 games
Compare with Seaver20.1
No. 1,569 all-time
Michael Conforto
right field, 2015–2025
7 seasons on the New York Mets, 2015–2021, 757 games
Compare with Seaver19.9
No. 1,595 all-time
Jeff Reardon
relief pitcher, 1979–1994
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1979–1981, 97 games
Compare with Seaver19.7
No. 1,612 all-time
Rick Aguilera
relief pitcher, 1985–2000
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1985–1989, 119 games
Compare with Seaver19.2
No. 1,672 all-time
Dave Magadan
third base, 1986–2001
7 seasons on the New York Mets, 1986–1992, 701 games
Compare with Seaver19.2
No. 1,686 all-time
Cleon Jones
left field, 1963–1976
12 seasons on the New York Mets, 1963–1975, 1,201 games
Compare with Seaver18.4
No. 1,767 all-time
Carl Everett
center field, 1993–2006
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1995–1997, 322 games
Compare with Seaver18.3
No. 1,780 all-time
Ron Darling
starting pitcher, 1983–1995
9 seasons on the New York Mets, 1983–1991, 272 games
Compare with Seaver18.0
No. 1,819 all-time
Hubie Brooks
shortstop, 1980–1994
6 seasons on the New York Mets, 1980–1991, 654 games
Compare with Seaver17.8
No. 1,844 all-time
Yoenis Cespedes
left field, 2012–2020
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 2015–2020, 316 games
Compare with Seaver17.8
No. 1,849 all-time
Armando Benitez
relief pitcher, 1994–2008
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1999–2003, 333 games
Compare with Seaver17.4
No. 1,913 all-time
John Stearns
catcher, 1974–1984
10 seasons on the New York Mets, 1975–1984, 809 games
Compare with Seaver17.3
No. 1,923 all-time
Mookie Wilson
center field, 1980–1991
10 seasons on the New York Mets, 1980–1989, 1,116 games
Compare with Seaver17.3
No. 1,931 all-time
Jay Bruce
right field, 2008–2021
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 2016–2018, 247 games
Compare with Seaver17.0
No. 1,972 all-time
Ed Charles
third base, 1962–1969
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1967–1969, 279 games
Compare with Seaver17.0
No. 1,958 all-time
Seth Lugo
starting pitcher, 2016–2025
7 seasons on the New York Mets, 2016–2022, 276 games
Compare with Seaver17.0
No. 1,964 all-time
Travis d'Arnaud
catcher, 2013–2025
7 seasons on the New York Mets, 2013–2019, 407 games
Compare with Seaver16.8
No. 1,993 all-time
Bernard Gilkey
left field, 1990–2001
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1996–1998, 380 games
Compare with Seaver16.6
No. 2,024 all-time
Randy Myers
relief pitcher, 1985–1998
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1985–1989, 185 games
Compare with Seaver16.5
No. 2,036 all-time
Angel Pagan
center field, 2006–2016
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 2008–2011, 393 games
Compare with Seaver16.5
No. 2,042 all-time
Brian McRae
center field, 1990–1999
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1997–1999, 300 games
Compare with Seaver16.3
No. 2,056 all-time
Donn Clendenon
first base, 1961–1972
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1969–1971, 281 games
Compare with Seaver16.1
No. 2,090 all-time
Don Cardwell
starting pitcher, 1957–1970
4 seasons on the New York Mets, 1967–1970, 103 games
Compare with Seaver15.7
No. 2,147 all-time
Jerry Grote
catcher, 1963–1981
12 seasons on the New York Mets, 1966–1977, 1,235 games
Compare with Seaver15.7
No. 2,148 all-time
Jason Isringhausen
relief pitcher, 1995–2012
5 seasons on the New York Mets, 1995–2011, 113 games
Compare with Seaver15.6
No. 2,154 all-time
Ray Knight
third base, 1974–1988
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1984–1986, 254 games
Compare with Seaver15.2
No. 2,227 all-time
Adam Ottavino
relief pitcher, 2010–2025
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 2022–2024, 192 games
Compare with Seaver15.1
No. 2,243 all-time
Bob Miller
relief pitcher, 1957–1974
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1962–1974, 99 games
Compare with Seaver15.0
No. 2,260 all-time
Juan Berenguer
relief pitcher, 1978–1992
3 seasons on the New York Mets, 1978–1980, 16 games
Compare with Seaver14.8
No. 2,296 all-time