Baseball GOATLoading rankings
Loading rankings
Ranked by career score. That covers a player’s whole career, not only his time with this team. Players need at least 3 seasons there to make the list.
Tom Seaver
starting pitcher, 1967–1986
6 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1977–1982, 160 games
Compare with Morgan83.0
No. 21 all-time
Joe Morgan
second base, 1963–1984
8 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1972–1979, 1,154 games
Compare with Seaver77.7
No. 25 all-time
Frank Robinson
right field, 1956–1976
6 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1960–1965, 906 games
Compare with Seaver74.5
No. 33 all-time
Tony Mullane
starting pitcher, 1881–1894
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1890–1893, 200 games
Compare with Seaver70.5
No. 42 all-time
Ken Griffey
center field, 1989–2010
9 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 2000–2008, 945 games
Compare with Seaver64.0
No. 66 all-time
Sam Crawford
right field, 1899–1917
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1899–1902, 403 games
Compare with Seaver60.0
No. 85 all-time
Pete Rose
third base, 1963–1986
19 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1963–1986, 2,722 games
Compare with Seaver59.6
No. 87 all-time
Carl Mays
starting pitcher, 1915–1929
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1924–1928, 117 games
Compare with Seaver56.3
No. 119 all-time
Johnny Bench
catcher, 1967–1983
17 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1967–1983, 2,158 games
Compare with Seaver54.5
No. 136 all-time
Eppa Rixey
starting pitcher, 1912–1933
13 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1921–1933, 440 games
Compare with Seaver54.0
No. 137 all-time
Bucky Walters
starting pitcher, 1931–1950
11 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1938–1948, 341 games
Compare with Seaver53.6
No. 145 all-time
Joey Votto
first base, 2007–2023
17 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 2007–2023, 2,056 games
Compare with Seaver52.4
No. 158 all-time
Barry Larkin
shortstop, 1986–2004
19 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1986–2004, 2,180 games
Compare with Seaver51.8
No. 167 all-time
Dolf Luque
starting pitcher, 1914–1935
12 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1918–1929, 403 games
Compare with Seaver51.3
No. 171 all-time
Noodles Hahn
starting pitcher, 1899–1906
7 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1899–1905, 238 games
Compare with Seaver48.1
No. 220 all-time
Frank Dwyer
starting pitcher, 1888–1899
8 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1892–1899, 279 games
Compare with Seaver47.8
No. 223 all-time
Elmer Smith
left field, 1886–1901
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1898–1900, 240 games
Compare with Seaver47.5
No. 233 all-time
Cesar Cedeno
center field, 1970–1986
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1982–1985, 429 games
Compare with Seaver46.8
No. 241 all-time
Edd Roush
center field, 1913–1931
12 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1916–1931, 1,399 games
Compare with Seaver46.6
No. 245 all-time
Theodore Breitenstein
starting pitcher, 1891–1901
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1897–1900, 156 games
Compare with Seaver45.8
No. 264 all-time
Joe Kelley
left field, 1891–1908
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1902–1906, 486 games
Compare with Seaver45.5
No. 275 all-time
Scott Rolen
third base, 1996–2012
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 2009–2012, 330 games
Compare with Seaver45.5
No. 274 all-time
Sherry Magee
left field, 1904–1919
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1917–1919, 216 games
Compare with Seaver44.7
No. 295 all-time
Ernie Lombardi
catcher, 1931–1947
10 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1932–1941, 1,203 games
Compare with Seaver43.3
No. 331 all-time
Kiki Cuyler
right field, 1921–1938
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1935–1937, 323 games
Compare with Seaver42.8
No. 343 all-time
Tony Perez
first base, 1964–1986
16 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1964–1986, 1,948 games
Compare with Seaver41.7
No. 366 all-time
Wally Berger
center field, 1930–1940
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1938–1940, 198 games
Compare with Seaver41.5
No. 369 all-time
Vada Pinson
center field, 1958–1975
9 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1960–1968, 1,384 games
Compare with Seaver41.3
No. 373 all-time
Cy Seymour
center field, 1896–1913
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1902–1906, 556 games
Compare with Seaver41.3
No. 374 all-time
Paul Derringer
starting pitcher, 1931–1945
10 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1933–1942, 393 games
Compare with Seaver40.7
No. 384 all-time
Heinie Groh
third base, 1912–1927
9 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1913–1921, 1,211 games
Compare with Seaver40.3
No. 393 all-time
Babe Herman
right field, 1926–1945
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1932–1936, 360 games
Compare with Seaver40.3
No. 396 all-time
Ice Box Chamberlain
starting pitcher, 1886–1896
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1892–1894, 110 games
Compare with Seaver39.7
No. 411 all-time
Billy Hoy
center field, 1888–1902
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1894–1902, 556 games
Compare with Seaver39.2
No. 432 all-time
George Foster
left field, 1969–1986
11 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1971–1981, 1,253 games
Compare with Seaver38.8
No. 444 all-time
Milt Pappas
starting pitcher, 1957–1973
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1966–1968, 86 games
Compare with Seaver38.4
No. 457 all-time
Eric Davis
center field, 1984–2001
9 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1984–1996, 985 games
Compare with Seaver37.8
No. 477 all-time
Red Lucas
starting pitcher, 1923–1938
8 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1926–1933, 590 games
Compare with Seaver37.6
No. 482 all-time
Bob Ewing
starting pitcher, 1902–1912
8 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1902–1909, 272 games
Compare with Seaver37.0
No. 498 all-time
Dave Parker
right field, 1973–1991
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1984–1987, 631 games
Compare with Seaver36.7
No. 507 all-time
Buddy Bell
third base, 1972–1989
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1985–1988, 386 games
Compare with Seaver36.2
No. 531 all-time
Jim Maloney
starting pitcher, 1960–1971
11 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1960–1970, 308 games
Compare with Seaver36.1
No. 534 all-time
Buck Ewing
catcher, 1880–1897
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1895–1897, 175 games
Compare with Seaver35.7
No. 548 all-time
Jose Rijo
starting pitcher, 1984–2002
10 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1988–2002, 281 games
Compare with Seaver35.6
No. 553 all-time
Jake Beckley
first base, 1888–1907
7 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1897–1903, 880 games
Compare with Seaver35.2
No. 564 all-time
Bid McPhee
second base, 1882–1899
10 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1890–1899, 1,227 games
Compare with Seaver35.1
No. 568 all-time
Johnny Cueto
starting pitcher, 2008–2024
8 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 2008–2015, 214 games
Compare with Seaver34.8
No. 576 all-time
Jim Bottomley
first base, 1922–1937
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1933–1935, 394 games
Compare with Seaver34.7
No. 580 all-time
Adam Dunn
left field, 2001–2014
8 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 2001–2008, 1,087 games
Compare with Seaver34.0
No. 607 all-time
Fred Toney
starting pitcher, 1911–1923
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1915–1918, 141 games
Compare with Seaver33.7
No. 622 all-time
Paul O'Neill
right field, 1985–2001
8 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1985–1992, 799 games
Compare with Seaver33.2
No. 646 all-time
Dutch Ruether
starting pitcher, 1917–1927
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1917–1920, 109 games
Compare with Seaver33.1
No. 649 all-time
George Burns
left field, 1911–1925
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1922–1924, 403 games
Compare with Seaver32.8
No. 655 all-time
Jake Weimer
starting pitcher, 1903–1909
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1906–1908, 86 games
Compare with Seaver32.6
No. 666 all-time
Edwin Encarnacion
designated hitter, 2005–2020
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 2005–2009, 514 games
Compare with Seaver32.2
No. 678 all-time
Kevin Mitchell
left field, 1984–1998
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1993–1996, 225 games
Compare with Seaver31.9
No. 695 all-time
Eugenio Suarez
third base, 2014–2025
7 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 2015–2021, 916 games
Compare with Seaver31.7
No. 704 all-time
Ken Griffey
right field, 1973–1991
12 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1973–1990, 1,224 games
Compare with Seaver31.6
No. 708 all-time
Chick Hafey
left field, 1924–1937
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1932–1937, 471 games
Compare with Seaver31.6
No. 709 all-time
Miller Huggins
second base, 1904–1916
6 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1904–1909, 790 games
Compare with Seaver31.4
No. 719 all-time
Gary Nolan
starting pitcher, 1967–1977
10 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1967–1977, 246 games
Compare with Seaver31.0
No. 741 all-time
Mike Donlin
center field, 1899–1914
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1902–1904, 220 games
Compare with Seaver30.9
No. 749 all-time
Billy Rhines
starting pitcher, 1890–1899
6 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1890–1897, 204 games
Compare with Seaver30.2
No. 779 all-time
Eddie Joost
shortstop, 1936–1955
6 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1936–1942, 443 games
Compare with Seaver29.9
No. 789 all-time
Dode Paskert
center field, 1907–1921
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1907–1921, 410 games
Compare with Seaver29.9
No. 791 all-time
Sonny Gray
starting pitcher, 2013–2025
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 2019–2021, 71 games
Compare with Seaver29.7
No. 810 all-time
Red Ames
starting pitcher, 1903–1919
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1913–1915, 95 games
Compare with Seaver29.3
No. 830 all-time
Johnny Vander Meer
starting pitcher, 1937–1951
11 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1937–1949, 348 games
Compare with Seaver29.2
No. 831 all-time
Joe Nuxhall
starting pitcher, 1944–1966
9 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1944–1966, 255 games
Compare with Seaver28.9
No. 845 all-time
Charlie Leibrandt
starting pitcher, 1979–1993
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1979–1982, 82 games
Compare with Seaver28.6
No. 863 all-time
Dave Concepcion
shortstop, 1970–1988
19 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1970–1988, 2,488 games
Compare with Seaver27.5
No. 927 all-time
Ken Raffensberger
starting pitcher, 1939–1954
7 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1947–1953, 244 games
Compare with Seaver27.5
No. 929 all-time
Pete Donohue
starting pitcher, 1921–1932
10 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1921–1930, 318 games
Compare with Seaver27.4
No. 936 all-time
Bret Boone
second base, 1992–2005
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1994–1998, 684 games
Compare with Seaver26.9
No. 970 all-time
Ted Kluszewski
first base, 1947–1961
7 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1947–1953, 830 games
Compare with Seaver26.7
No. 979 all-time
Joe Adcock
first base, 1950–1966
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1950–1952, 332 games
Compare with Seaver26.5
No. 988 all-time
Reggie Sanders
right field, 1991–2007
8 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1991–1998, 805 games
Compare with Seaver26.4
No. 1,001 all-time
Bill Doran
second base, 1982–1993
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1990–1992, 260 games
Compare with Seaver26.3
No. 1,007 all-time
Lonny Frey
second base, 1933–1948
7 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1938–1946, 941 games
Compare with Seaver26.0
No. 1,022 all-time
Hal McRae
designated hitter, 1968–1987
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1968–1972, 247 games
Compare with Seaver25.9
No. 1,025 all-time
Hank Sauer
left field, 1941–1959
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1941–1949, 234 games
Compare with Seaver25.9
No. 1,024 all-time
Jake Daubert
first base, 1910–1924
6 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1919–1924, 801 games
Compare with Seaver25.5
No. 1,057 all-time
Mario Soto
starting pitcher, 1977–1988
12 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1977–1988, 303 games
Compare with Seaver25.4
No. 1,061 all-time
George Suggs
starting pitcher, 1908–1915
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1910–1913, 150 games
Compare with Seaver25.3
No. 1,070 all-time
Johnny Bates
center field, 1906–1914
4 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1911–1914, 420 games
Compare with Seaver25.1
No. 1,086 all-time
Ed Bailey
catcher, 1953–1966
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1953–1961, 147 games
Compare with Seaver24.8
No. 1,113 all-time
Tommy Harper
left field, 1962–1976
6 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1962–1967, 648 games
Compare with Seaver24.7
No. 1,124 all-time
Bob Purkey
starting pitcher, 1954–1966
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1960–1964, 169 games
Compare with Seaver24.3
No. 1,152 all-time
Bronson Arroyo
starting pitcher, 2000–2017
9 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 2006–2017, 294 games
Compare with Seaver24.2
No. 1,164 all-time
Luis Castillo
starting pitcher, 2017–2025
6 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 2017–2022, 137 games
Compare with Seaver24.1
No. 1,167 all-time
Bug Holliday
center field, 1889–1898
9 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1890–1898, 795 games
Compare with Seaver24.1
No. 1,170 all-time
Ewell Blackwell
starting pitcher, 1942–1955
8 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1942–1952, 222 games
Compare with Seaver24.0
No. 1,177 all-time
Don Gullett
starting pitcher, 1970–1978
7 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1970–1976, 254 games
Compare with Seaver23.8
No. 1,198 all-time
Hans Lobert
third base, 1903–1917
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1906–1910, 600 games
Compare with Seaver23.6
No. 1,208 all-time
John Smiley
starting pitcher, 1986–1997
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1993–1997, 125 games
Compare with Seaver23.6
No. 1,210 all-time
Harry Gumbert
starting pitcher, 1935–1950
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1944–1949, 196 games
Compare with Seaver23.4
No. 1,231 all-time
Jimmy Barrett
center field, 1899–1908
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1899–1906, 168 games
Compare with Seaver23.2
No. 1,259 all-time
Harry Steinfeldt
third base, 1898–1911
8 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1898–1905, 894 games
Compare with Seaver23.0
No. 1,278 all-time
Ramon Hernandez
catcher, 1999–2013
3 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 2009–2011, 269 games
Compare with Seaver22.9
No. 1,285 all-time
Larry Benton
starting pitcher, 1923–1935
5 seasons on the Cincinnati Reds, 1930–1934, 158 games
Compare with Seaver22.7
No. 1,298 all-time