Baseball GOATLoading rankings
Loading rankings
Ranked by career score. That covers a player’s whole career, not only his time with this team. Players need at least 3 seasons there to make the list.
Lefty Grove
starting pitcher, 1925–1941
9 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1925–1933, 402 games
Compare with Collins84.0
No. 20 all-time
Eddie Collins
second base, 1906–1930
13 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1906–1930, 1,156 games
Compare with Grove82.8
No. 22 all-time
Jimmie Foxx
first base, 1925–1945
11 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1925–1935, 1,256 games
Compare with Grove75.9
No. 28 all-time
Eddie Plank
starting pitcher, 1901–1917
14 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1901–1914, 530 games
Compare with Grove74.9
No. 31 all-time
Nap Lajoie
second base, 1896–1916
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1901–1916, 374 games
Compare with Grove74.3
No. 35 all-time
Rickey Henderson
left field, 1979–2003
14 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1979–1998, 1,704 games
Compare with Grove74.1
No. 36 all-time
Reggie Jackson
right field, 1967–1987
10 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1967–1987, 1,346 games
Compare with Grove57.9
No. 102 all-time
Mark McGwire
first base, 1986–2001
12 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1986–1997, 1,329 games
Compare with Grove55.4
No. 128 all-time
Rube Waddell
starting pitcher, 1897–1910
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1902–1907, 252 games
Compare with Grove55.2
No. 130 all-time
Al Simmons
left field, 1924–1944
12 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1924–1944, 1,290 games
Compare with Grove52.8
No. 151 all-time
Jason Giambi
first base, 1995–2014
8 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1995–2009, 1,036 games
Compare with Grove49.7
No. 186 all-time
Dennis Eckersley
starting pitcher, 1975–1998
9 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1987–1995, 525 games
Compare with Grove48.1
No. 219 all-time
Tim Hudson
starting pitcher, 1999–2015
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1999–2004, 188 games
Compare with Grove47.9
No. 222 all-time
Mickey Cochrane
catcher, 1925–1937
9 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1925–1933, 1,167 games
Compare with Grove47.8
No. 227 all-time
Jack Quinn
starting pitcher, 1909–1933
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1925–1930, 184 games
Compare with Grove47.7
No. 229 all-time
Bob Shawkey
starting pitcher, 1913–1927
3 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1913–1915, 73 games
Compare with Grove47.6
No. 232 all-time
Bob Johnson
left field, 1933–1945
10 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1933–1942, 1,459 games
Compare with Grove47.1
No. 238 all-time
Home Run Baker
third base, 1908–1922
7 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1908–1914, 899 games
Compare with Grove46.8
No. 242 all-time
Charles Bender
starting pitcher, 1903–1925
12 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1903–1914, 434 games
Compare with Grove46.0
No. 257 all-time
Herb Pennock
starting pitcher, 1912–1934
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1912–1915, 70 games
Compare with Grove45.3
No. 281 all-time
Catfish Hunter
starting pitcher, 1965–1979
10 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1965–1974, 378 games
Compare with Grove44.6
No. 297 all-time
Sal Bando
third base, 1966–1981
11 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1966–1976, 1,468 games
Compare with Grove44.4
No. 306 all-time
Vida Blue
starting pitcher, 1969–1986
9 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1969–1977, 276 games
Compare with Grove42.8
No. 342 all-time
Eddie Rommel
starting pitcher, 1920–1932
13 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1920–1932, 508 games
Compare with Grove42.8
No. 340 all-time
Bobo Newsom
starting pitcher, 1929–1953
5 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1944–1953, 114 games
Compare with Grove42.7
No. 344 all-time
Miguel Tejada
shortstop, 1997–2013
7 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1997–2003, 936 games
Compare with Grove40.5
No. 388 all-time
Bullet Joe Bush
starting pitcher, 1912–1928
7 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1912–1928, 196 games
Compare with Grove40.2
No. 398 all-time
Gene Tenace
catcher, 1969–1983
8 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1969–1976, 805 games
Compare with Grove40.0
No. 403 all-time
Josh Donaldson
third base, 2010–2023
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2010–2014, 405 games
Compare with Grove39.7
No. 414 all-time
Wally Schang
catcher, 1913–1931
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1913–1930, 575 games
Compare with Grove39.2
No. 433 all-time
Rick Monday
center field, 1966–1984
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1966–1971, 639 games
Compare with Grove37.5
No. 486 all-time
Jose Canseco
right field, 1985–2001
9 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1985–1997, 1,058 games
Compare with Grove37.2
No. 491 all-time
Jason Kendall
catcher, 1996–2010
3 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2005–2007, 373 games
Compare with Grove37.0
No. 497 all-time
Ned Garver
starting pitcher, 1948–1961
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1957–1960, 115 games
Compare with Grove36.1
No. 532 all-time
Bob Welch
starting pitcher, 1978–1994
7 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1988–1994, 216 games
Compare with Grove35.8
No. 540 all-time
Tony Phillips
left field, 1982–1999
9 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1982–1999, 941 games
Compare with Grove35.6
No. 558 all-time
Jose Rijo
starting pitcher, 1984–2002
3 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1985–1987, 72 games
Compare with Grove35.6
No. 553 all-time
Davey Lopes
second base, 1972–1987
3 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1982–1984, 347 games
Compare with Grove35.3
No. 561 all-time
Dan Haren
starting pitcher, 2003–2015
3 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2005–2007, 102 games
Compare with Grove34.1
No. 604 all-time
Marcus Semien
shortstop, 2013–2025
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2015–2020, 773 games
Compare with Grove33.9
No. 611 all-time
George Kell
third base, 1943–1957
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1943–1946, 313 games
Compare with Grove33.2
No. 640 all-time
Carney Lansford
third base, 1978–1992
10 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1983–1992, 1,203 games
Compare with Grove32.7
No. 663 all-time
Mickey Tettleton
catcher, 1984–1997
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1984–1987, 283 games
Compare with Grove32.7
No. 657 all-time
Jack Coombs
starting pitcher, 1906–1920
9 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1906–1914, 329 games
Compare with Grove32.5
No. 668 all-time
Bobby Shantz
starting pitcher, 1949–1964
8 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1949–1956, 245 games
Compare with Grove32.2
No. 679 all-time
Rube Walberg
starting pitcher, 1923–1937
11 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1923–1933, 415 games
Compare with Grove31.9
No. 690 all-time
Bert Campaneris
shortstop, 1964–1983
13 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1964–1976, 1,795 games
Compare with Grove31.7
No. 705 all-time
Topsy Hartsel
left field, 1898–1911
10 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1902–1911, 1,147 games
Compare with Grove31.4
No. 725 all-time
Howard Ehmke
starting pitcher, 1915–1930
5 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1926–1930, 88 games
Compare with Grove31.1
No. 738 all-time
Ken Holtzman
starting pitcher, 1965–1979
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1972–1975, 159 games
Compare with Grove30.9
No. 742 all-time
Danny Murphy
second base, 1900–1915
12 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1902–1913, 1,412 games
Compare with Grove30.1
No. 780 all-time
Eddie Joost
shortstop, 1936–1955
8 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1947–1954, 917 games
Compare with Grove29.9
No. 789 all-time
Harold Baines
designated hitter, 1980–2001
3 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1990–1992, 313 games
Compare with Grove29.8
No. 795 all-time
Pinky Higgins
third base, 1930–1946
5 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1930–1936, 589 games
Compare with Grove29.8
No. 799 all-time
Sonny Gray
starting pitcher, 2013–2025
5 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2013–2017, 114 games
Compare with Grove29.7
No. 810 all-time
Lave Cross
third base, 1887–1907
5 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1901–1905, 676 games
Compare with Grove29.3
No. 827 all-time
Barry Zito
starting pitcher, 2000–2015
8 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2000–2015, 225 games
Compare with Grove29.3
No. 824 all-time
Eric Chavez
third base, 1998–2014
13 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1998–2010, 1,320 games
Compare with Grove28.4
No. 879 all-time
Dwayne Murphy
center field, 1978–1989
10 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1978–1987, 1,213 games
Compare with Grove28.1
No. 900 all-time
Matt Chapman
third base, 2017–2025
5 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2017–2021, 573 games
Compare with Grove27.4
No. 932 all-time
Nellie Fox
second base, 1947–1965
3 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1947–1949, 98 games
Compare with Grove27.3
No. 942 all-time
Dave Stewart
starting pitcher, 1978–1995
8 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1986–1995, 257 games
Compare with Grove27.3
No. 937 all-time
Wally Moses
right field, 1935–1951
10 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1935–1951, 1,170 games
Compare with Grove27.2
No. 951 all-time
Matt Olson
first base, 2016–2025
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2016–2021, 575 games
Compare with Grove27.1
No. 959 all-time
Gio Gonzalez
starting pitcher, 2008–2020
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2008–2011, 95 games
Compare with Grove26.8
No. 975 all-time
Max Bishop
second base, 1924–1935
10 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1924–1933, 1,183 games
Compare with Grove26.6
No. 983 all-time
Jeff Burroughs
right field, 1970–1985
3 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1982–1984, 292 games
Compare with Grove26.5
No. 989 all-time
Amos Strunk
center field, 1908–1924
13 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1908–1924, 1,030 games
Compare with Grove26.5
No. 995 all-time
Frankie Hayes
catcher, 1933–1947
11 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1933–1945, 992 games
Compare with Grove25.9
No. 1,027 all-time
Rollie Fingers
relief pitcher, 1968–1985
9 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1968–1976, 503 games
Compare with Grove25.8
No. 1,031 all-time
Jimmy Dykes
third base, 1918–1939
15 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1918–1932, 1,703 games
Compare with Grove25.5
No. 1,053 all-time
Mike Torrez
starting pitcher, 1967–1984
3 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1976–1984, 45 games
Compare with Grove25.4
No. 1,060 all-time
George Earnshaw
starting pitcher, 1928–1936
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1928–1933, 219 games
Compare with Grove25.3
No. 1,066 all-time
Elmer Valo
right field, 1940–1961
15 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1940–1956, 1,361 games
Compare with Grove25.1
No. 1,083 all-time
Terry Steinbach
catcher, 1986–1999
11 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1986–1996, 1,199 games
Compare with Grove24.7
No. 1,117 all-time
Tillie Walker
left field, 1911–1923
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1918–1923, 737 games
Compare with Grove24.7
No. 1,118 all-time
Nels Potter
starting pitcher, 1936–1949
5 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1938–1948, 128 games
Compare with Grove24.3
No. 1,145 all-time
Sam Gray
starting pitcher, 1924–1933
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1924–1927, 141 games
Compare with Grove23.9
No. 1,190 all-time
Harry Davis
first base, 1895–1917
16 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1901–1917, 1,415 games
Compare with Grove23.6
No. 1,213 all-time
Socks Seybold
right field, 1899–1908
8 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1901–1908, 975 games
Compare with Grove23.6
No. 1,206 all-time
Ferris Fain
first base, 1947–1955
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1947–1952, 844 games
Compare with Grove23.3
No. 1,241 all-time
Jermaine Dye
right field, 1996–2009
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2001–2004, 394 games
Compare with Grove23.2
No. 1,247 all-time
Ramon Hernandez
catcher, 1999–2013
5 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1999–2003, 595 games
Compare with Grove22.9
No. 1,285 all-time
Mike Moore
starting pitcher, 1982–1995
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1989–1992, 138 games
Compare with Grove22.8
No. 1,291 all-time
Phil Garner
second base, 1973–1988
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1973–1976, 358 games
Compare with Grove22.5
No. 1,325 all-time
Nick Swisher
right field, 2004–2015
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2004–2007, 458 games
Compare with Grove22.1
No. 1,365 all-time
Dave Henderson
center field, 1981–1994
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1988–1993, 702 games
Compare with Grove22.0
No. 1,371 all-time
Barney McCosky
center field, 1939–1953
5 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1946–1951, 442 games
Compare with Grove22.0
No. 1,372 all-time
Dave Kingman
left field, 1971–1986
3 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1984–1986, 449 games
Compare with Grove21.5
No. 1,410 all-time
Stan Bahnsen
starting pitcher, 1966–1982
3 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1975–1977, 67 games
Compare with Grove21.2
No. 1,451 all-time
Sam Chapman
center field, 1938–1951
11 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1938–1951, 1,274 games
Compare with Grove21.2
No. 1,455 all-time
Chris Bassitt
starting pitcher, 2014–2025
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2015–2021, 100 games
Compare with Grove21.0
No. 1,480 all-time
Bill North
center field, 1971–1981
6 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1973–1978, 669 games
Compare with Grove21.0
No. 1,473 all-time
Kurt Suzuki
catcher, 2007–2022
7 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2007–2013, 718 games
Compare with Grove20.6
No. 1,510 all-time
Eddie Smith
starting pitcher, 1936–1947
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1936–1939, 88 games
Compare with Grove20.4
No. 1,542 all-time
Ray Herbert
starting pitcher, 1950–1966
5 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1955–1961, 153 games
Compare with Grove20.3
No. 1,548 all-time
Bing Miller
right field, 1921–1936
12 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1922–1934, 1,361 games
Compare with Grove20.3
No. 1,545 all-time
Rick Honeycutt
starting pitcher, 1977–1997
8 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1987–1995, 390 games
Compare with Grove20.1
No. 1,566 all-time
Jed Lowrie
second base, 2008–2022
7 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 2013–2022, 876 games
Compare with Grove20.1
No. 1,566 all-time
Norm Siebern
first base, 1956–1968
4 seasons on the Athletics franchise, 1960–1963, 611 games
Compare with Grove19.9
No. 1,588 all-time